I agree. However, I'd have tons more confidence in the new head gasket. Look at the aftermarket one vs the new green one. There is a single piece of metal on the cylinder-crowns for the new one? The old aftermarket looks like six different rings assembled on the asbestos-looking material?Typically the protocol is to machine the heads mating surface when a there is a head gasket failure. At a minimum check it for flatness. I hope your repair works out for you. At this point I would cross my fingers and run it.
Torque in incremental steps, and sequence, for tightening or loosening. Check head bolt torque after the specified amount of use (whatever that is). Use clean head bolts, and lubricate the threads prior to installation (whatever that means).