When I first rebuilt my 8274, I replaced the motor with a new Chinese one from DB Electric. After only a couple of months and a few pulls, it started working intermittently, in either direction. The intervals of it working became further and further apart. It would have stranded me in the bottom of Dark Canyon in S. Utah, except I was with a group and other trucks had winches that worked. When I got home and tore the DB Electric motor apart, I found this:
View attachment 2028026
A bunch of the copper had worn or burned right off of the armature! Again, this motor was brand new. Just really poor quality control I guess. So, if the armature just happened to stop turning when it had copper contact with both brushes, or if it got bumped a little and brought the brushes into contact with the copper, it might start again the next time.
I replaced it with a new Warn 9.5XP motor and all has been well for eight years and many pulls since.
But remembering this, and as you mentioned you also put a new motor in yours - what motor did you put in?