Definitely the latter. As in, the clip at the end of the axle. While maybe “countless (millions)” of times have seen them reused, it’s also clearly listed as a non-reusable part in the parts diagram in post 305 on page 16 of this thread. I can’t imagine how any retaining C clip in any application is considered a reusable part. (See also - birfields.) The only way to remove it is to deform it after use by use of pliers. Again, it’s not like this was a stab in the dark. I called and asked the questions I thought were needed and made it clear that I was ready to order whatever was needed for the job, to the degree that some things I had in my cart and ready to purchase were removed based on recommendation. In other words, it’s not like I cheaped out on a c clip. That would have been far cheaper to order than the new flanges and spindles I was prepared to buy if needed And asked about. More on birfields below.
View attachment 2954573
Agreed. They were clicking, so I ordered new ones. Those c clips were included.
This isn’t a question of parts that are considered reuse items. In case of failure, I ordered flange hardware replacement kits to get new cone washers, washers, and nuts. A standby set of studs, and a steering arm replacement hardware kit just in case.
There were surprises all around with the job so far, some good and some bad. This isn’t a character assassination, but people need to be aware that the “kit” doesn’t include replacement parts. Finding this out during reassembly is frustrating to say the least.
Could be worse. It could be the TG spindle nut gadget that doesn’t even fit on the axle. Fail. Maybe FZJ’s have a different size drive axle or something.