@UTadventures the issue isnt whether the dissent bumper or the slee blueberry will survive, its will it protect your hood, grille, and headlights. ARB with the reinforced bar work has been proven to plow deer head on, in the corner, w/e and take almost no damage. I think with the bumpers that have no upper barwork theres a chance the struck deer could cause some body work damage to your grill, hood, or headlights.
That all makes sense. For me, personally, any front bumper buy would be for off road recovery facilitation, really just a place to stick a winch. There are plenty of deer here, but not so close to people that they wind up causing TOO too much havoc on the roads. But if I lived up in the midwest or northeast in one of those places where apparently there's more deer than people and/or the population density of both is such that there's too much overlap... I'd probably want the upper hoops too.