Thanks for the feedback. My truck is currently blowing somewhere between cool and outright hot with the slider set to 65 degrees depending on the ambient temperature of the truck (i.e. garage temp versus having sat out in the midday sun) but it's also 95+ degrees this week and an 11 on the UV index... mercifully I just got my truck back from the tint shop yesterday so now have 15% tint on the front windows, and 12% everywhere else. It's a little more murdered out looking than I'd like, but the sun out here is no joke so I'm happy to be driving in the shade!I agree that a shroud can only help, but I am going to wait and see how my AC handles without the shroud before I start working on a custom one.
The cummins naturally runs cool, and that mechanical fan is massive compared to the OEM fan. For those running the intercooler up high there is additional restriction to pull air through the I/C, condensor and radiator, but I doubt a shroud will be required given the additional air volume capacity of the cummins fan over toyota fan. For those running the DA I/C down low, there is no additional restriction.
Are you having A/C issues now or is this a theoretical debate?
I've apparently got leaky high and low side hoses, and the popoff valve is leaky too. The fan clutch, compressor, o-rings and shrader valves were just swapped out and I've had the freon freshly recharged. My builder thinks like you do - that the Cummins fan is so big that it doesn't need a shroud, but I can fully understand the logic behind creating as much low pressure behind the radiator as possible... but it also looks like a lot of fabrication to make something fit my complicated-ass truck. One issue is that the low side hose contacts the corner of the DA airbox, so it might rub through over time.
Good news is, my builder's swapped truck and the others he has done all do NOT have shrouds and none of them have the same issue I do, so hopefully it's isolated to my parts. It probably says something about the overall complexity and expense of these trucks that I'm pretty excited that the estimate is ONLY $300 to fix my A/C!