Thanks
@cruiseroutfit . It is actually the second, see above. These shocks needed to be rebuilt and this one snapped a week before we planned to remove them. The CV was not damaged thankfully and just needed a reboot.
Unfortunately, ARB would not rebuild or warranty my set of BP-51's until they had them in hand. This did not sound promising, but a rebuild was cheaper than a new suspension so decided to pursue this option. I didn't have a set of stock shocks on hand and reached out to Cruiser Outfitters who had a few sets of take-offs. These were needed so the truck could be driven (it is my daily) during the 4-6 week shipping and rebuild process at ARB.
After closer examination during suspension removal, it was clear that these shocks could not be rebuilt. ARB was not willing to help any further and I made the decision to move on from this suspension.
I tried calling Cruiser Outfitters today to see if they would consider returning my unopened stock suspension parts. While I was more than willing to pay for the return shipping and even a restocking fee, the person on the phone just kept saying I was past the return policy and used parts could not be returned. He was unwilling to consider the position that ARB had put me in and the realities of timing when rebuilding a suspension.
I hope this provides some lessons learned for the 200 community regarding BP-51's and future rebuilds.