and always follow the advice of the folks that took your money....
watch your spark plugs over the next few weeks - if you start getting specs on the insulator (the bit below the electrode), we'll need to revisit this.
When the folks that took my money build quadrajets for a living, and have a good reputation for standing behind their products, I'll give them the benefit of the doubt until I have reason not to.
That isn't to say I don't have five or six other valid opinions and options in the responses here. I'm certain the 4-hole gasket would work just as well. Better? Time will tell, if I can't get this one dialed in properly, that's the next step I'll take. I'm getting a bunch of different messages here - from different gaskets, to adapters to entirely different intakes. Can't try them all at once!
I simply can't understand how running an adapter is going to help in this case. The baseplate gasket mates the top of the intake perfectly, I have no external leaks at the base, and it's the base gasket provided by the rebuilder as a match for the carb he provided.
I'm a scientist - by nature I try to limit variables to one thing at a time. Aside from less mixture screw response than I'd expect, I really don't have any outward signs of a vacuum leak (eratic idle, stumbling, etc.) anywhere aside from the choke.
All signs point to a leak in the choke housing, but I'm not seeing a reason to suspect the baseplate.
As for the plugs - unfortunately they probably won't be too telling. The valve seals are toast so the plugs end up pretty black pretty quickly. Alternatively, some of the blackness might also be a result of all the futzing around I've done with the prior carb and timing over the past few months, plus loads of prolonged idling. I'll probably drop in a new (clean) set of plugs and see what they look like after a few tens of miles of driving.
Naturally, I mean no disrespect or offense to anyone who willing provide advice/insight as willingly as you all do...obviously I'm pretty green when it comes to this stuff and maybe I'll end up eating some serious crow, just trying to approach this one variable at a time.