I went through a similar deal a few weeks ago. I ended up learning that the Optima batteries have issues and even though they seemed to be the most rebound brand, decided against them. I took a simple approach with my research on this, called 3 different battery shops in my local area and asked how often the yellow tops were coming back in under warranty. I was shocked that one shop had 3 returned already that week. He said they have anywhere from 2-6 come back each week.
I ended up going with the Odyssey Performance AGM2 battery. Note: they have an extreme version but they are being discontinued due to problems. They are now pushing the AGM2.
I went ahead and replaced the terminals while I was at it with new OEM. Pricey little suckers. $13 for the left and $32 for the right I think.
View attachment 2695525