Replace that PCV valve (1 Viewer)

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

mine was still rattling at 140k miles but I did see oil leaking past the PCV, my intake had oil and even the spark plug wells had oil.
I think we should change it more frequently like 60-80k for engine and exhaust system longevity.
Spark plug wells are a separate issue that @Taco2Cruiser (I think) has written about. Not a great job to address.
 
So I replaced mine this weekend and noticed quite a bit of gunk buildup in the tube. What’s the best way to get rid of that stuff or do I just need to sea foam the engine oil? Doesn’t look like the valve had ever been replaced on mine in 168k
 
So I replaced mine this weekend and noticed quite a bit of gunk buildup in the tube. What’s the best way to get rid of that stuff or do I just need to sea foam the engine oil? Doesn’t look like the valve had ever been replaced on mine in 168k
A new hose retails for about $17, $10 on the retail sites. 12261-38020

I would strongly advise against seafoam.. that is very, very old tech and modern engines oils are not... old tech. They have pretty advanced chemistry and what seafoam would do to that balance is anyone's guess. Not to mention potentially attacking rubber seals, etc.

Just keep on top of your oil changes and run a high quality synthetic for their detergent additives and hit the road.
 
A new hose retails for about $17, $10 on the retail sites. 12261-38020

I would strongly advise against seafoam.. that is very, very old tech and modern engines oils are not... old tech. They have pretty advanced chemistry and what seafoam would do to that balance is anyone's guess. Not to mention potentially attacking rubber seals, etc.

Just keep on top of your oil changes and run a high quality synthetic for their detergent additives and hit the road.
Sorry, not the hose, the actual tube that the pcv screws into. The pcv was stuck open and there was a buildup of grime down into the engine.
I tried to clean out what I could
 
Sorry, not the hose, the actual tube that the pcv screws into. The pcv was stuck open and there was a buildup of grime down into the engine.
I tried to clean out what I could
Ohhh.. yeah that would be a lot more expensive and involved to replace.
 
Last edited:
Did mine this weekend. 2008 with 143k. It was bad. No rattle at all. Had my 12 year old helping and was showing him how to check it. Told him to hold it up to his ear and shake it. He told me the new one had something broken inside because it rattled and the old one didn’t. Had to explain how it worked.
666FFB87-CBDC-4EDC-96B9-7A9118C4C5C6.jpeg
 
The factory tire iron will double a PCV remover.
When removing the PCV, take note of how much force is used. The PCV is made of plastic, and I can only assume it wouldn't take much force to strip it.

View attachment 3105096View attachment 3105097
This (tire iron) worked like a charm.

I tightened mine to basically where it was tight in turning and wouldn’t turn anymore without putting force on it if that makes sense. Should that be tight enough? I felt like if I tightened it anymore it could potentially break/crack.

Mine wasn’t completely clogged, but it almost was. The new one rattled a ton and the old one was barely ratting.
 
I tightened mine to basically where it was tight in turning and wouldn’t turn anymore without putting force on it if that makes sense. Should that be tight enough?
Yep, if not a little too tight. You should be able to pretty much remove by hand, or maybe just a hair over.
 
I replaced mine a few days ago, I'm pretty sure it was the original part with 175k miles and was stuck open. Unfortunately I can report that there was no increase in my dismal fuel economy. :frown:

20221210_120449.jpg
 
This thread is very interesting.

A few weeks ago I was coasting into a gas station and got and engine light and notices low oil pressure. Shut it down and coasted to station. Truck needed 6 liter of oil to get onto dip stick. Bottom was covered with oil. I figured I'd thrown a rod or something terrible...


Towed it home put it in the shop... removed and drained oil and skids plates.... changed the oil. Started it up. Ran great, no knocks, no nothing....
no leaks.... none... zip zero.....
Washed the truck off the bottom and looked again.... not so much as a drip.....been driving ever since... running like a top but i've been terrified without a root cause. One mchanic suggested PCV problem that pushed the oil out.

Just ordered a new one.....

Also the day it let its oil out was -30C so very cold.... I'd driven in 5 hours at that point though....

Anyway super interesting.
 
I replaced mine a few days ago, I'm pretty sure it was the original part with 175k miles and was stuck open. Unfortunately I can report that there was no increase in my dismal fuel economy. :frown:

View attachment 3194926

Give it time maybe, if you have scanning you could watch if the trims improve.
 
Circling back to green tip vs black tip. When I bought my replacement valve the other day, Toyota parts guy mentioned there could be a minor weight difference in the small rattle ball inside the actual valve designed for flex fuel Pcv valve and Toyota denotes that by having two specific part numbers for what appears to be the same part with different color tips?? He said either would work but I stuck to the black one.
 
Circling back to green tip vs black tip. When I bought my replacement valve the other day, Toyota parts guy mentioned there could be a minor weight difference in the small rattle ball inside the actual valve designed for flex fuel Pcv valve and Toyota denotes that by having two specific part numbers for what appears to be the same part with different color tips?? He said either would work but I stuck to the black one.

Black
 
For what it is worth I still have the green one in mine and everything is running perfect (Probably around 10-11k miles later)
 
So how did you guys get that foam out to replace the PCV valve without destroying it?
 
Never mind - mine seemed to pretty much just rip in half at the slightest pressure. Y'all think it's ok just to jam back in there, or should I try and get an intact piece?
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top Bottom