Hi. I may be reading and responding too late for you. I had my 1969 FJ40 repainted last summer. Since I am the original owner, I wanted to keep the FJ as original as possible. I researched the paint colors extensively. Below is what I learned about the silver/pewter trimmed items at least through model year 1972. I am very pleased with the final product and the color of the silver/perter is a very close match if not perfect.
Front Bumper, Rear Bumperettes, Side Mirrors, Front Turn Signals, License Plate Light, Interior Parts
Original Color: Silver/Pewter Metallic; Two Toyota Colors are Referenced:
- Gray M [for metallic] Toyota Color # T1434 (thought to be used beginning in 1968)
- Ash Gray Metallic Toyota Color # T145 (most restoration shops use this color but one source indicated that Toyota did not produce this color until 1983)
NOTE: Everything I have read indicates the bumpers, side mirror arms, front turn signals, and license plate light were the same color as the interior instrument panel cover, ash tray, and glove box door.