A very worn Toyota key of the same era can open worn lock cylinders pretty easily.
Most excellent news! Glad you got it back.I GOT HER BACK! I'm grateful to report that My FJ60 was found today and she's back home. Got the call from SFPD this afternoon. Thankfully other than ransacked glovebox, console and a few random tools missing, she was in the same shape when she left. As far as how she was stolen - no signs of forced entry on door (thinking slim jim), hatch, etc. and no sign of damage around ignition key. Its like the thief had the extra key I've been meaning to have made for the last 6 months.
Thank you all for the words of encouragement and a special shout at to @chelo for driving around some pretty spicy parts of SF looking for my rig. Last few days have been very stressful and I've been playing a lot of shoulda, woulda, coulda on how I could have done a better job preventing this. Thanks for the all the tips, suggestions on theft prevention. I'm glad I'm getting a second chance to implement them. I got lucky getting mine back in one piece.