I'm thinkinag about the same choice, I'm very curious if a 9.5 inch tire sticks out beyond the rear fenders. I'm thinking of going back to my stock rims, so I know that will help. Right now I have 7 inch white spoke wrims with 235/75R 15's The sidewall just barely protrudes beyond the rear fender/body side. I have BFG AT, which tuck in tighter than the old ELdorado ZR4 AT's I had originally, the sidewall really ballooned on them.
My reasoning, is I do not want flares, and I do not like the tires throwing mud and road spray all over the side of the rig. I want that crap trapped in the fender so it can properly rust through in there

But seriously, do they stick out or not. My measurements all say they do, but most guys pics look like they stay in nicely, especially on stock rims.
Oh and Jwood, as for the 30 inch tire, I'm considering that too, but pricing them online, it seems they are several dollars more than a 235/75, and you only gain about half an inch of diameter, probably not worth the money.
I know at full stuff on my stock rig, the 235's are very close to touching things. I don't think 33's will do well without a lift, but maybe they work.
Anyone know what happens at full stuff, opposing corners, like a big ditch scenario or something???