Head gasket failures in 5.7s (2 Viewers)

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Oct 26, 2016
Threads
12
Messages
54
Location
Florida
I watched a video last night about Toyotas discontinuing of the 5.7L V8, and if it would be that great if they brought it back. After watching the rather informative video, which explained a problem with the engines blowing head gaskets, and why, I came away feeling these 5.7s arent quite as bullet proof as I had felt.

Definitely a robust design mechanically, and undoubtedly one of the best normally aspirated engines out there, but because of the aluminum block and heads that can’t be Decked or surfaced to correct slight warpage , often caused by overheating from a blown steel head gasket, without the sourcing of thicker head gaskets to make up for what is removed during the decking/resurfacing process, to keep the valve timing correct, it makes addressing a blown head gasket potentially ludicrously expensive.

The collection this shop had of blown head gaskets from Toyota aluminum block, aluminum head with steel head gasket engines was convincing, that regular oil and coolant changes was critical to help extend the life of these engines.

The owner of the 2013 LC 200 with 200k miles, that was the center of the video, was in for a huge let down with the reality he was up against a repair that would most likely exceed the value of his vehicle, which is 5 years newer than mine with 350k… so I’m now thinking any use I get from mine from this point forward should be considered a blessing…

Thinking about what we are going to buy to replace it, I can’t think of anything other than a newer LC or LX, but only with low miles knowing anything with a lot of miles can be the next one with a costly blown head gasket,

They mentioned the “UZ” V 8s with iron blocks and heads regularly going over 500k to 600k, but I’m not familiar with those engines.

With an American V8 SUV, engine replacement or rebuilding is at least palatable , with thousands of used engines and parts available at far more reasonable prices.

No, not comparable to a LC or LX, but far more manageable when things do go South and you need to rebuild or replace the engine.

I’m now wondering just how many 5.7s actually made it to 500k…
 
Beginning to think these head gaskets are immortal, based on the fact that the stupid ccn video drama won’t just die.
 
Beginning to think these head gaskets are immortal, based on the fact that the stupid ccn video drama won’t just die.
Not understanding why you feel the ccn video is stupid. It simply exposes an issue with these 5,7s that exists but also explains more timely coolant replacements can perhaps delay.

All engines have life expectancies, some better than others, but 200k on one if these 5.7s is too soon, so if nothing else, forum readers might tend to change out their coolant and other fluids even sooner now, which is the message I got out of the video..which isn’t a stupid video at all….
 
Not understanding why you feel the ccn video is stupid. It simply exposes an issue with these 5,7s that exists but also explains more timely coolant replacements can perhaps delay.

All engines have life expectancies, some better than others, but 200k on one if these 5.7s is too soon, so if nothing else, forum readers might tend to change out their coolant and other fluids even sooner now, which is the message I got out of the video..which isn’t a stupid video at all….
Just so I know where you're coming from, have you actually looked into the 15-page thread linked above dedicated to the video that prompted your post?

And especially the plentiful data that what he predicts out of high-mileage coolant isn't actually happening?
 
Not understanding why you feel the ccn video is stupid. It simply exposes an issue with these 5,7s that exists but also explains more timely coolant replacements can perhaps delay.

All engines have life expectancies, some better than others, but 200k on one if these 5.7s is too soon, so if nothing else, forum readers might tend to change out their coolant and other fluids even sooner now, which is the message I got out of the video..which isn’t a stupid video at all….
Sit down and drink your red koolaid like you were told.
 
Just so I know where you're coming from, have you actually looked into the 15-page thread linked above dedicated to the video that prompted your post?

And especially the plentiful data that what he predicts out of high-mileage coolant isn't actually happening?
I” I object, it’s argumentative!”…… no seriously, I read the string of posts , and have seen a few videos from the same entity that made the one with the 2013 200 with 200k on the clock, and he’s definitely familiar with Toyota products including the 5,7s…..z enough where is comment and opinion “holds water” …..definitely better than the blown steel head gasket he discovered along with a stack of others..

Sorry, but I simply don’t consider his comments or video stupid…..and I’m betting he’s serviced and repaired more of these vehicles than just about everyone that has seen it.

I own one and have no interest in buying anything else as an SUV because of what they are and how they drive, I simply looked at the 5.7s as easy 500k engines, which I now believe is a reach. Thats OK, as I’m not aware of any near 6 litre gas fueled engine that can easily reach half a million miles WO a rebuild…

Now back to another Schofferhofer….
 
I” I object, it’s argumentative!”…… no seriously, I read the string of posts , and have seen a few videos from the same entity that made the one with the 2013 200 with 200k on the clock, and he’s definitely familiar with Toyota products including the 5,7s…..z enough where is comment and opinion “holds water” …..definitely better than the blown steel head gasket he discovered along with a stack of others..

Sorry, but I simply don’t consider his comments or video stupid…..and I’m betting he’s serviced and repaired more of these vehicles than just about everyone that has seen it.

I own one and have no interest in buying anything else as an SUV because of what they are and how they drive, I simply looked at the 5.7s as easy 500k engines, which I now believe is a reach. Thats OK, as I’m not aware of any near 6 litre gas fueled engine that can easily reach half a million miles WO a rebuild…

Now back to another Schofferhofer….

I don't want to s*** on the guy, he mostly produces good, informative content, but he is a content creator and does have a vested interest in getting views. There were at least three threads already devoted to this video, the big one as noted having 15 pages at this point.

He was also wrong in another video about the purpose of the spring in the base of the oil filter housing cover.

Your direct question asking about how many 5.7s made it to 500k.. as I understand it, like many toyota products, quite a few. The original million mile tundra guy hit 900k in January on the 5.7 toyota gave him to replace his original. I don't see an article but I'd bet he's over 1M by now. There are reports online of a handful of 4.6's (same engine family) over a million, and at least another 5.7 that went up for sale.

So with all the discussion in the other thread, data people posted about the condition of their coolant, speculation about other causes of HG failures, very easy to find evidence that the 3UR isn't actually a ticking time bomb, what is the point of this thread then?
 
I don't want to s*** on the guy, he mostly produces good, informative content, but he is a content creator and does have a vested interest in getting views. There were at least three threads already devoted to this video, the big one as noted having 15 pages at this point.

He was also wrong in another video about the purpose of the spring in the base of the oil filter housing cover.

Your direct question asking about how many 5.7s made it to 500k.. as I understand it, like many toyota products, quite a few. The original million mile tundra guy hit 900k in January on the 5.7 toyota gave him to replace his original. I don't see an article but I'd bet he's over 1M by now. There are reports online of a handful of 4.6's (same engine family) over a million, and at least another 5.7 that went up for sale.

So with all the discussion in the other thread, data people posted about the condition of their coolant, speculation about other causes of HG failures, very easy to find evidence that the 3UR isn't actually a ticking time bomb, what is the point of this thread then?
I had heard of some seriously high mileage Toyotas , and saw a number of 1 M km examples when we lived briefly in Qld, but they were all diesels and most had bodies that looked like they were ready to fall off ( Aussies like to chase and run from waves as they trek down the beach I’m told )… We owned a petrol V6 Prado we wished we could have brought home, but came back knowing we wanted a 200 .

I’m actually feeling we might get lucky and get to that 500k mark, if we stay on a more frequent maintenance plan…but as we are the second owners and the first shouldn’t own one, we’ve been a bit concerned ours will make it….

Not a whole lot we can do except change fluids and hoses often( which we have ) and make sure we don’t overheat it which has never happened under our watch.
 
I’m actually feeling we might get lucky and get to that 500k mark, if we stay on a more frequent maintenance plan…but as we are the second owners and the first shouldn’t own one, we’ve been a bit concerned ours will make it….

Not a whole lot we can do except change fluids and hoses often( which we have ) and make sure we don’t overheat it which has never happened under our watch.
change your coolant every 10k miles

change your head gasket every 50 k miles as preventative maintenance

watch that youtube guy more than you watch porn

then your 200 will reach 500 k miles

Since you are an ex Prado owner - hope the lord helps you in your recovery of poor life decisions
 
change your coolant every 10k miles

change your head gasket every 50 k miles as preventative maintenance

watch that youtube guy more than you watch porn

then your 200 will reach 500 k miles

Since you are an ex Prado owner - hope the lord helps you in your recovery of poor life decisions

This @ryanCA fella gets it...

Also, @bloc the original million mile Tundra had the 4.7 motor. I havent heard of a 5.7 hit a mil, link?

Cool tear down of the million mile Tundra:

 
This @ryanCA fella gets it...

Also, @bloc the original million mile Tundra had the 4.7 motor. I havent heard of a 5.7 hit a mil, link?

Cool tear down of the million mile Tundra:


This was posted here in January, original million mile guy was close in his newer replacement:


A 2019 5.7 with 900k in June:



One over a million that went up for sale is referenced in a video but I can’t find more about it.
 
This was posted here in January, original million mile guy was close in his newer replacement:


A 2019 5.7 with 900k in June:



One over a million that went up for sale is referenced in a video but I can’t find more about it.


Holy hell!

Having owned that exact Tundra I’m curious how he did all those miles in the stock seats. Impressive
 
But seriously, how long would it take most of you to make it 500k miles? At least for me, with my Chevy bolt being used as a daily driver most of the time, the LC might see 500k miles after I have died and my children have great grand children. Seriously. I think im around 6k miles since I bought it in early February, 8 months. So it looks like im probably on track for about 10k miles. Ill let you guys know how its going in 50 years.

And, even if you did get that far, is replacing the motor once REALLY that big of a deal? Like if in 20 years I had to replace my 5.7L, I dont think I would be all that upset.

In 15 years my kids will both be out of the house and my wife and I can buy a 2 door electric truck with 40" tires from the factory and 2000 mile range.
 
But seriously, how long would it take most of you to make it 500k miles? At least for me, with my Chevy bolt being used as a daily driver most of the time, the LC might see 500k miles after I have died and my children have great grand children. Seriously. I think im around 6k miles since I bought it in early February, 8 months. So it looks like im probably on track for about 10k miles. Ill let you guys know how its going in 50 years.

And, even if you did get that far, is replacing the motor once REALLY that big of a deal? Like if in 20 years I had to replace my 5.7L, I dont think I would be all that upset.

In 15 years my kids will both be out of the house and my wife and I can buy a 2 door electric truck with 40" tires from the factory and 2000 mile range.
I will be at 500K on my 200 in 38 months.
 
change your coolant every 10k miles

change your head gasket every 50 k miles as preventative maintenance
If someone cannot do this in their garage, then how much is this “preventive” plan over the 200k miles? 500k miles? That Toyota dealer or garage will be rolling out the red carpet!! This type of plan pretty much negates the whole point of buying a Toyota!

If i am gonna spend THAT much on preventive services, then might as well get a freaking Land Rover and enjoy the up to date technology and Apple CarPlay!
 
If someone cannot do this in their garage, then how much is this “preventive” plan over the 200k miles? 500k miles? That Toyota dealer or garage will be rolling out the red carpet!! This type of plan pretty much negates the whole point of buying a Toyota!

If i am gonna spend THAT much on preventive services, then might as well get a freaking Land Rover and enjoy the up to date technology and Apple CarPlay!
I missed your daily trolling with your Ford F150

Welcome back.


While you were gone we are doing weekly radiiator flushes and monthly HG changes in our garage. So often that my kids can now do it before school.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top Bottom