The great winch data table:
View attachment 2946769
Top selection criteria - it fits, it's light, it's got good warranty, and the brake type is not opaque.
Winner: Carbon 12k v2 (available at
www.carbonwinches.com), the USA distributor. Responds to questions.
Runnerup: Runva 11xp. Available at home depot. Only $670. Drawback - it's heavier by 18lb. The US importer shorts the warranty a bit.
Runnerup: Novawinch Pro 12500 (
www.novawinch.us). It's the Superwinch Talon gen 2, but the IP got sold to Novawinch when Superwinch was sold to Westin. Good ratio, but a bit heavy, and the warranty is shorter. Very forward design in the brake, HP, and ratio. Responds to questions.
Runnerup: Sherpa4x4 Colt. Light, good warranties. The clocking and lever doesn't work for my install (by about 5 mm). Responds to questions.
Best new product: The xbull XRS - very interesting! Dual speed is super cool, and I bet works well in practice for most recoveries (101:1). Didn't fit in my install though. And service is not a thing. They didn't respond to email or the website chat. <Edit - two days later I did get answers to my chats and emails. So there is a heartbeat, though a slow one. I asked technical questions (like what type of brake?) and got two different answers (drum, gearbox). Sigh.>
My bumper has a 185mm height limit, so some weren't a fit (clutch wouldn't rotate, or just too tall). Other installs may not have this issue.