I wish you'd consulted me before you started with the sheet metal Ted. I want to cut all mine out and redo it with underbed storage and some sort of slide outs behind the cab. You had it all open, and still just did a flat bottom and flat sides. Tons easier, yes. But sooo much wasted space; space that could've been utilized to keep your CoG lower, tools & parts cleaner, and making individual items more accessible. Hell, since you're doing a new winch, that too can go underneath in the back to save space, protect the winch, and allow to pull front or rear with one winch. (Did you ever see my setup on ol' Rusty Red?)
As for the winch...
The first gets my vote in most categories. Looks cooler, more waterproof, has wireless.
However, the solenoid pack is not as easily moveable for remote mounting if desired and the whole thing weighs a lot more (probably a good thing for long term durability though). I'd say do the comp version with syn line and a Hawse unless you're going to consider mounting in the back like I mentioned above. In that case, do the regular steel cable.