i’ll chime in too as i’m in similar situation. first winter in CO. i’m on the nATs 255/75/17. i’m very happy on how their are performing on the packed snow roads, and powder, much better than the fairly new ko2s i swapped out. i wish i could compare them to a true snow tire just to see. right now i can’t get up my driveway with my front wheel drive mazda6 on new blizzaks, but i walk right up in the 470 with the nATs. And with the nATs, i know i have great off road AT function in the same tire once i get off the pavement. right now. LMK if you have any other questions or thoughts@w4lks0ftly curious if you have any further updates from your Colorado winter?
Still can’t decide if I’m going dedicated winters or nAT. If I’m able to safely cruise down icy and snowpack passes powder chasing, I think just going with the nAT seems like the way. I would sell my slightly used Defender LTXs, save $150 dollars on second wheels, and time/few $ on slightly used winters.