I've recently used 2 bags of B&B Hickory Lump from Academy on my BGE (large). Both bags were mostly small pieces, like finger-sized branches and quarter-to-half dollar-size chunks with way less than 25% any bigger than that. Kind of disappointing, but the flavor was good. I didn't add any other hickory chunks so I could see what the B&B would do. Last cook was 16lbs of pork at 250* for 8-9 hours. I filled the firebox and there was nothing left when I was done - finished cooking on residual heat. Lots of ash. I'll continue to buy it in hopes of getting bigger chunks next time. They also stock it in mesquite and maybe oak near here.
I also used the B&B for some stuff at 375* and hard a hard time maintaining temp. Firebox holes were getting plugged. I won't use it for med to hi temp anymore because of that, unless they start using bigger chunks.
Royal Oak has been good for me, especially since it's so easy to find. I seems to get a handful of rocks in each bag. Cowboy will never be bought again due to massive sparking, massive ash, and non-wood crap in the bag. Pity, because there were always lots of large chunks per bag.
Playing around with coal placement and lighting has yielded some good results. I think Spressoman turned me on to that.
BGE lump can just be stooopid money around here, so I have to try to remember to look for it when I'm out of town (and I usually forget). I've always had very good luck getting lots of large chunks from them.
I also used the B&B for some stuff at 375* and hard a hard time maintaining temp. Firebox holes were getting plugged. I won't use it for med to hi temp anymore because of that, unless they start using bigger chunks.
Royal Oak has been good for me, especially since it's so easy to find. I seems to get a handful of rocks in each bag. Cowboy will never be bought again due to massive sparking, massive ash, and non-wood crap in the bag. Pity, because there were always lots of large chunks per bag.
Playing around with coal placement and lighting has yielded some good results. I think Spressoman turned me on to that.
BGE lump can just be stooopid money around here, so I have to try to remember to look for it when I'm out of town (and I usually forget). I've always had very good luck getting lots of large chunks from them.