
Correction, the KO2s in 37x12.5s are about 5lbs per lighter per tire compared to 35x12.5 Nitto Ridge Grapplers which are a more durable hybrid tire, thus the weight difference (10-ply tread).
I've found both to be about equal in terms of noise which was a pleasant surprise as the Nittos have a more aggressive MT looking sidewall.
I think I just have to give 37s a try. I can always fall back to 35s if any regrets. One thing I will not do is change my current suspension setup to make 37s work. It's just too dialed in to sacrifice for better looks.