If you don’t need an LT rated tire for what you do, I would not buy an LT rated tire. The weight, stiffer sidewalls and higher required pressures will impact ride, traction, and braking, arguably more than which tire brand you pick.Man, I just picked up some Rock Warriors and I'm bummed to learn now that the Defender only comes in E-load in 17" (285/70). The XL would be probably be perfect for my needs. Maybe blasphemy in this thread but should I consider the C-load BFGs instead? I've run E-load BFGs on other vehicles and they were unpleasant but I have no other experience with E tires. I assume there's little hope the M/S 2 will come out in new configs in a 17" at this point.
Falken Wildpeak, Toyo Open Country AT, and BFGoodrich Trail Terrain, among others, all come in 285/70r17 in a P rated tire. I love my Michelin Defenders but I wouldn’t love LT-E rated anything.