I am of the opinion that you are placing way too much importance on that single collector. what is wrong with using a y-pipe if it works?
You are overlooking more important differences. The tuned ceramic headers by ManAFre that I have been running for 6 years are better in the following ways than your "new style header":
1. they are tuned (equal exhuast pressure in each pipe)
2. they are hot jet coated with ceramics inside and out. Mine have no signs of any rust after 6 years. they are still pretty.
3. mine came with the Toyota OEM gasket
4. mine has the heat riser option that allows for easy cold starts. (but perhaps yours does too.
5. I still like the idea of a true two piece header. Wouldn't it more likely mate perfectly with the head? I can't say for sure, but the above 4 reasons are enough for me.
The only downside is that they cost over $550 today with the heat riser and the y-pipe (plus delivery).
so, by "New Style Headers", you mean that these are the new style inexpensive and inferior headers. these are the ones I bought
MAF Tuned Ceramic Coated Headers F and 2F Engines
I don't see what you are placing so much importance on mine needing a Y-pipe. I think the best thing about the "new style headers" is that they have borrowed the flange design of the headers I bought from them. It is thick. Doesn't say laser cut, but at least its thick. I think that is the most important design change of the new style headers.
If you are expecting more power and fuel economy it willl be so small you won' notice it. I went with these headers because I was sick of developing exhaust leaks with that inferior design of the factory exhaust manifold/header. I haven't had an exhaust leak since. Mine have been trouble free. I just make sure that they are re-torqued every 18 months or so.
I don't think that headers are something you want to save money on, because if you do, it could end up costing you a lot more time, money and hassle in the long run.