Timely thread for me. I was just trying to work this out with State Farm. They would not let me in on what my current valuation is on my truck (what they would pay out in the event of it being stolen or wrecked), but did say I could do an agreed upon value if I had the truck appraised. Not sure if the they would only agree on the appraised value putting the valuation in the hands of the appraiser or if you could reach an agreement with them based on the appraised value as a starting point and go from there. My agent is actually trying to talk me out of doing that as they think my truck is insured as needed without an agreed upon value. They claim that if the truck were wrecked or whatever they would take into consideration the selling price of recent FJ60 sales in my area in addition to NADA book when determining a payout amount. So therefore claim I am insured appropriately now without an agreed upon value. Without knowing what the current payout would be I am not sure if I believe that. My truck is not really a museum piece time capsule type of truck, but its all stock and un-molested with no rust and I still think its worth more than what they would pay out with how I had it insured now. So not sure what to do here myself and am anxious to see where this thread goes.