I got told once that the 1HZ was designed to repaired in the field without gaskets,it is a very user friendly engine.
If it wasnt leaking ,there maybe some truth in it.
Normally ,the pump has a plastic gasket with a ridge on it,I think they are called a "crush gasket".
The aftermarket waterpumps always have a metal impeller,while the OEM pump has a plastic impeller and the vanes are sharper.
Most of the aftermarkets pumps seem to perform ok,but I think from looking at the OEM pump,it will pump coolant more efficiently.
In oz ,its only about $30 extra for the OEM,so its a no brainer.
The 1st pump on my HZJ75 lasted 250000klms