These pix were taken a couple of years ago. The rigs wheel together often, run most trails together, the Nitto’s are more often on the more aggressive line and have run more trails than the BFG’s.
Most of the locals that wheel have switched from the BFG’s. They appear to have a harder tread compound for long highway tread life, so don’t grip as well and chunk more than average.
My Coopers pictured above were purchased used, the rears (pictured) were older than the fronts. The fronts have much less chunking and have been on the exact same trails. Tires get harder as they age, most are very hard at 4yrs, old tires have less grip, slip more, chunk more, have much more tendency to be out of round, separate, etc. When buying tires take the miles per year that you drive into account, if the rig doesn’t see a lot of miles, a softer, more aggressive tire is probably a better tire. Plan for them to wear out in less than 4yrs, 3 yrs is better.