Anybody change ATF after 163K?

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

I debated this and changed it at 200K. I just couldn't justify, in any way, that dirty fluid being better than clean. So far so good.

Changed how? Nobody seems to debate new is better than old, the question/debate seems to be more about what way to do it safely. Gradually, safely DIY, or flush in one way or another....
 
As long as you don't take it to a shop to have them hook to any type of power flushing machine you should be fine. The consensus is generally you can change the fluids all at once. You do run the risk of the detergents in the the atf breaking some deposits loose but our transmissions are stouter than most. It could mean a rebuild but we have heard stories both ways. If you are concerned start by replacing just the 3 qts that drain out. Drive then repeat. Then when most of the fluid is new you can decide if you want to drain and refill it completely later. The only problem with this method is the fluid is never completely clean and fresh. Then again, you have not introduced all of the cleaning/detergents into the old system at once either.
 
I had mine done at Toyota using the fluid exchanger at approximately 178k on my 2006. I am currently at 198k with no ill effects, and perhaps a slightly smoother shift when cold.

Was it the first time it was done?

I debated this and changed it at 200K. I just couldn't justify, in any way, that dirty fluid being better than clean. So far so good.

Was it the first time it was done?
 
I did 4 drain and fills over the course of a week with 159k on it, and it was the first service according to the PO. I replaced the original fluid with M1 synthetic. So far so good but I haven't put many miles on it, just 3 miles each way back and forth from work and then a few errands here and there.

I sure hope I haven't done any harm. The original fluid was pretty clean looking but did have a pretty foul, somewhat burnt smell to it. Mine is a 2000 fwiw.
 
As long as you don't take it to a shop to have them hook to any type of power flushing machine you should be fine. The consensus is generally you can change the fluids all at once. You do run the risk of the detergents in the the atf breaking some deposits loose but our transmissions are stouter than most. It could mean a rebuild but we have heard stories both ways. If you are concerned start by replacing just the 3 qts that drain out. Drive then repeat. Then when most of the fluid is new you can decide if you want to drain and refill it completely later. The only problem with this method is the fluid is never completely clean and fresh. Then again, you have not introduced all of the cleaning/detergents into the old system at once either.

Mine has 207K miles when I bought it - no history of fluid change. I have some receipts that goes back several years, but not from the beginning. The original fluid looks good, no burnt smell. I have done drain and refill 2x in the past 7K miles with Mobil 1 synthetic with the thinking of introducing fresh fluid slowly, but I plan to flush it out. I dont think the car was used off roading or towing by previous owner, so it has had easy life.

The power steering fluid was in really bad shape. It was black and thick (I should have kept a small sample of fluid for comparison). I have drain and refill the reservoir several time to slowly introduce M1 fluid. It is now dark red, but at least now it feels smooth and liquid. The fluid change color to lighter shade of red when new fluid gets introduced, but then it goes darker red, which seems to support the idea that it is cleaning some deposits. There is a small improvement to the feel of steering, but that could be my imagination. I am also planning to flush it out, most likely in the summer.
 
I did 4 drain and fills over the course of a week with 159k on it, and it was the first service according to the PO. I replaced the original fluid with M1 synthetic. So far so good but I haven't put many miles on it, just 3 miles each way back and forth from work and then a few errands here and there.

I sure hope I haven't done any harm. The original fluid was pretty clean looking but did have a pretty foul, somewhat burnt smell to it. Mine is a 2000 fwiw.

Yours uses the WS fluid correct?
 
Well I am glad to hear that some people here have done the WS fluid exchange for the first time with over 150K. I think it is ok to do.
 
I was looking at a local land cruiser and the owner has all the service records but it never had any trans service. I looked some of it up and it is supposed to be lifetime whatever that means. It is called world standard fluid.

I am not sure about not doing anything though. Has anybody here done a trans fluid flush for the first time with at least 163K on the clock?

Thanks

Mark
I have an 2000 LX470. Has 249,000 on it now. Did first time flush around 247,800. Have had no issues. Still changes sooth and pressure hasn't changed. I'm glad I did it. Bought car with 67,000 on it.
 
I have an 2000 LX470. Has 249,000 on it now. Did first time flush around 247,800. Have had no issues. Still changes sooth and pressure hasn't changed. I'm glad I did it. Bought car with 67,000 on it.

Wow. I think I am ok then. Yours uses the WS right? Was the fluid black? Did yours ever tow or anything?
 
I will be doing a "power"flush (not the DIY) with WS next week. 160K+ on mine, no clue as to previous history.

After talking to a specialist, I don't see the risk. And if it breaks afterwards, then surely something was already wrong I just accelerated the need for a repair.
 
Was it the first time it was done?



Was it the first time it was done?


I didn't have a record that it had ever been done. I could have been, but couldn't confirm.
 
Most drain about 3 quarts with every oil change. If you remove the transmission drain plug 3 quarts will flow out and no more. If you do this with every oil change I doubt a transmission flush will be necessary. Besides many think a flush can cause issues and would advise against it. It another way for a shop to sell something you may not need. If you want to replace all the fluid there are threads here to step you through. Changing and flushing are two different procedures. Go with the change as a suggestion.

What about changing the filter? I assume these trannies have a filter in them?
 
A filter is not the term I would use. It's a mesh screen. And catches only the biggest crap to prevent further damage to the total system in case of some sort of (catastrophic) failure. This is not an oil or fuel filter type deal that needs changing.
 
Engine Types

Some one waste the $28 already! (Where's the Lexus owners at?)

I already changed mine, so little to be learned.
 
Update: 255K kilometers. Just had it flushed. 50 miles in seems to work fine. The ATF I had was dark and smelled burned bad. In any case, worth it as PM in my book. Powerflush, so they add a detergent, I cycle the gears a few minutes, and the old fluid + detergent is pushed out and new ATF is flushed in.

The ATF was aftermarket WS that the flush place uses.

Our guess is that ATF was never changed, judging by how the hose was stuck to the radiator.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top Bottom