Well said, David. There's really no *best option*. FWIW, I also have a nice backpack style tent that I've taken on trips on which the trailer/tent wasn't a good choice.
My trailer requires minimum maintenance, although it does occupy 1/4 of my garage. It solves the issue of saving a campsite, you just unhitch and go. Perfect for wheeling/Cruiser events, where a large part of those attending show up with trailers, RV's or pop-ups. I've actually towed mine over some rough trails, or as rough as it gets for me. It's not like you're going to drive up Moab Rim towing it, and most people don't camp up there anyway. If you're really into the hardcore stuff, then one of these tents is not for you; on a trailer they add complexity and limit your reach, on the roof they can really throw your COG off. I prefer driving to see places than to spend a day moving over VW-sized boulders in a hot canyon to advance a couple of miles at best. Good fun, just not my cup of tea. The rooftent works in my application.
Yes, they're expensive, but you just can't compare the comfort level, ease/speed of setup, and improved security.
Tell you what, I hope to hit one more Cruiser event this year and maybe a couple in 2006. If you see me there, come over and check the trailer out, you can even climb into the tent and try it out.
My trailer requires minimum maintenance, although it does occupy 1/4 of my garage. It solves the issue of saving a campsite, you just unhitch and go. Perfect for wheeling/Cruiser events, where a large part of those attending show up with trailers, RV's or pop-ups. I've actually towed mine over some rough trails, or as rough as it gets for me. It's not like you're going to drive up Moab Rim towing it, and most people don't camp up there anyway. If you're really into the hardcore stuff, then one of these tents is not for you; on a trailer they add complexity and limit your reach, on the roof they can really throw your COG off. I prefer driving to see places than to spend a day moving over VW-sized boulders in a hot canyon to advance a couple of miles at best. Good fun, just not my cup of tea. The rooftent works in my application.
Yes, they're expensive, but you just can't compare the comfort level, ease/speed of setup, and improved security.
Tell you what, I hope to hit one more Cruiser event this year and maybe a couple in 2006. If you see me there, come over and check the trailer out, you can even climb into the tent and try it out.