OK ordering tires tomorrow. I'm the most damn indecisive person I know, at least I got to the the make/model, Nitto Trail Grappler, if nothing else because I can get them at a nice discount.
It's a toss up and i'm going to sit on it for one more day. I tore another sidewall in a BFG AT, I have two spares that I can use to replace it but the remaining tread depth of any of the tire doesn't warrant a free (would be prorated though) replacement anymore. I still have the set of six 16" wheels in my shed and still like the idea of keeping the ATs for trips and winter.
I'm going to either be ordering the 315/75R16 or the 295/70R18
The info is out there and both sizes give me concerns but I gotta pick one.