Interesting, and of course I have a lot of respect for Kurt's opinions. My personal experience with them comes from two trucks. I've got them on my wife's 80 and it's seen some fair wheeling, including the Rubicon, and so far I've had no problems. Early on in my 60's life I had them in the knuckles, again without problem, before switching to a Diamond front housing with their keyed knuckle/steering arm assembly.
I've had a theory for a while now that part of the problem with knuckle studs to begin with is that they are over torqued regularly on wheeling vehicles. A lot of trail tightening of knuckle studs is to just get whatever wrench fits and pull really hard, get some movement on the nut, and call it good. So, over time they can be overtightened, yielding them, and then they stretch, thin, and ultimately break. From my perspective this connection is not what in the structural world we would call a "slip critical" connection, meaning we would rely on friction created by bolt pretension clamping two surfaces together to transfer shear. Instead we would refer to this as a "bearing" connection. With the greasy nature of the assembly the bolts are going to transfer the shear forces through direct bearing of the bolt (although I make sure the surfaces are as clean as I can get them when assembling). The ARP studs will be stronger in shear than stock studs, and if you adhere to the torque specs you shouldn't strip out the knuckle, so a win-win in my book. Front Range Off Road recommends using Red loctite at the knuckle side to prevent loosening, so when I put them in my wife's 80 I made sure to thoroughly degrease the threaded holes in the knuckles before installing the ARP studs with loctite.