Hi Jfcol,
I don't think sealing around the screw heads will solve your problem, as the water gets in in-between the outside moulding and the A pillar, the A pillar is hollow and open at the bottom, so when the rivet holes are damaged water gets in and finds it’s way down to whatever is below and in it’s path, and usually the first thing of consequence is electrical, after that it's the carpet in the footwells.
As I said before, self tapping screws are the worst, as they not only make the holes even bigger but also raise the edge of the metal as they cut their own thread, also the outside mouldings holes will be damaged, so new mouldings will be needed.
I had the same problem inherited from the pervious owner, and this is my work around and it has worked for the last 9 years with no water ingress.
New parts required but not limited to….
Disclaimer, these are the parts I used on my 2004 LC 100, you will need to check if they fit your model year.
Minimum 8 rivets (I would get 16, 8 spares) Toyota Part number 90269-04053
Right side moulding Toyota Part number 7553360031
Left side moulding Toyota part number 7553460021
Moulding outside No.2 left and right are the same part number 7554360020, they are not strictly necessary as they only cover the rivet heads and do nothing for water tightness. See picture above in my previous post.
Windscreen adhesive kit from eBay, Do NOT use silicone.
I would get 4 new good quality 4mm drill bits, 3 of them are for just-in-case.
Main tools required, but not exclusive…
Small battery Drill, as you will be working close to glass, you don’t want to scratch the glass while the chuck is turning, I used a piece of cardboard between the glass and the spinning chuck, to try to protect the glass as much as possible.
Pop rivet gun, small hand held, there is a ‘special tool’ ‘pop rivet gun’ with a narrow head to enable access to the channel in the moulding when installing the new ‘special pop rivets', I just grinned each side of the head of my pop rivet gun to make it fit, as the correct installation of the new pop rivets is crucial.
A tool to remove the fixings that are holding your existing moulding in, ie, screws or wrong size rivets.
Procedure…
Remove old mouldings, you’ll see that the the moulding are fixed with double sided tape from the top of the screen glass into the gutter, make sure you remove all the old double sided tape residue from the paintwork in the gutter, otherwise the new moulding that come with the double sided tape already attached won’t adhere.
Now is the time to check the flat part of the a pillars for rust rust or wot-not, so in other words the part of the A pillar with the four holes in where the moulding was fixed to, make sure this surface is clean and flat, and that any exposed metal is treated, ie, touch-up paint, if the existing holes have raised edges on them, tap them gently down and in awards to the A pillar cavity, these holes will not be used again.
Use a little of the windscreen/windshield adhesive you bought from eBay to fill the holes,
do not use silicone, smooth the adhesive flat to the A pillar while still pliable, so now your A pillar is flat and clean with no holes.
Take your two new moulding and drill four new 4mm holes approx 10mm away from the existing holes in the new mouldings, it’s your call if you drill them above or below the existing holes, you just don’t want them to interfere with the old holes that you just filled/repaired in the A pillar.
Once the new holes are drilled in the new mouldings check for burrs, offer the mouldings up to the A pillars, secure them in place with tape as if they were in their fixed and in there final position, make sure the moulding are fixed very well with the tape so that the moulding won’t move, using the new moulding with the new holes as a ‘template’ (you could temporally blank off the old holes so’s not to mistake them) carefully and slowly take you time to drill four new 4mm holes in to the A pillar using the the new holes in the moulding as guides, make sure your drill is as straight and square as possible, obviously this procedure would be a lot easier if the screen was not fitted.
BTW, if you ever have a new screen fitted, remove the moulding yourself, don’t let the screen fitter do it, because that’s how this all started, in my case the fitter bought new moulding as the existing moulding are not easy to remove without damaging them, I told him not to fit the new mouldings and that I would fit them myself, I had to sign to say he had not fitted the moulding, but at least by fitting myself I had peace of mind that they would not leak.
Finally (yes I know it’s a saga) remove the temporally taped secured mouldings, touch up the 8 new holes to prevent rust, doesn’t matter what paint you use as long as it will prevent rust, as this part of the A pillar is not seen once the moulding is fitted. Wait for paint to dry.
Offer the new moulding up to the A pillar again, this time use the four each side new special pop rivets (do not pop the rivets yet) to temporally check the position and correct fit of the moulding, remember I mentioned that the top most part of the moulding have double sided tape fitted to them, now remove the top three rivets leaving the bottom one in place (this next part is what I found the trickiest) so the bottom rivet is still in place as a guide, then remove the backing covering the double sided tape, (you only get one shot at this part) then carefully and slowly lower the moulding down ( keeping the bottom pop rivet in place, as a hinge (suppose you could say), now press the part with the double sided tape firmly down into the gutter, if you don’t make sure the area is very clean the tape won’t adhere.
Now that the mouldings are in place, and the new holes in the mouldings and the new holes in the A pillars are lined up, you will now see why the pop rivet gun needs to be modified, it’s a tight squeeze, now fit the new special pop rivets in the pop rivet gun, keeping the rivet and gun nice and square to the pillar, you can now place the rivets in the holes and pop them.
This is what I did and it worked, you may find variations on the theme, but the whole point is not to do a bodge-job.
Feel free to ask question or criticise, as in no way do I consider myself an ‘expert’ in any field, every days a school day, free speech is aloud in my house, as long as you’re not to offensive. Also, please excuse spelling and punctuation mistakes, but I think you'll get the drift.
Below is an extract from the FSM with regard to the fitment of the rivets.
View attachment 3214306
View attachment 3214416