New one came in. Aisin part not toyota direct. Plugged it in, tested it and it worked flawlessly, confirming something is definitely wrong with mine. Took it apart, clocked it, put it back together, tested again, and worked great. So, going to go ahead and disassemble the old one like in the video, leaving the rods in place, and using this new one. Never messed with the hi/low side of the actuator so I'll have to familiarize myself with the clocking of that one since I sorta never paid too much attention to that portion of the video...
Oh, and the microswitch of this new one seems exactly like my old one. Springy, no click. So, I don't know what the heck is up with the old one.

Oh, and the microswitch of this new one seems exactly like my old one. Springy, no click. So, I don't know what the heck is up with the old one.