Roof Rack:
Back in November, I posted a
thread inquiring about folks' experience with roof racks. I basically have analysis paralysis, having not found anything that 100% meets my desires. My shortlist of wants/needs includes:
- Low-profile, to fit in my garage and the occasional public parking garage (overall height needs to remain under 6'8", or only slightly higher than the factory load bars.)
- Flat top for hauling plywood, furniture, etc. (because this is how I am going to be using it more often than not).
- Maximum flexibility in tying stuff down; I need to be able to use ropes, bungees, ratchet straps, cargo nets, etc.
- Maximum flexibility for attaching lights, accessories, and wiring.
- Ability to mount a Yakima or Thule cargo box without additional rails/fittings.
- Needs a front wind deflector, and the ability to mount a front-facing light bar BELOW the load floor is a plus.
There's basically three commercial options that I am considering:
- Gamiviti Expo (or Trail Tailor, of similar design)
- Bowfin Cruisers (I love the overall look and 80/20 extrusion design and wind deflector, but I have serious reservations about how the rack mounts to the roof using spacers in the roof channel--an issue with all Prinsu-style racks)
- Dissent (my second favorite look--second to Bowfin--and it seems like the most thoughtful, well-engineered option. It is also the most expensive and seems not to be as flexible in terms of tie-down options. If I was buying a roof top tent, this would probably be my platform of choice.)
I also started kicking around the idea of building my own, using Gamiviti towers and building a platform out t-slot extrusions. I struggled with how to design the corners, how to integrate a wind deflector, and other details. After a lot of design and redesign in AutoCAD, I've come up with a design that I think is at least viable.
This design is 80" X 52" inches, using 1X2 10-series extrusions. There are 7 load bars (50" wide) with another 1X2 to mount the deflector. The side rails are also 1X2, positioned vertically. This should give a lot of extra resistance to deflection--per the calculator, the side rails should deflect only about .004" with a 600 lb load. The Gamiviti towers will mount directly to the 2nd, 5th, and 7th bars, as counted from the front.
I abandoned trying to make a radiused or chamfered corner on the back of the rack in favor of some plates and bolts to finish off the corner. The deflector mount uses some standard 10-series joining plates to mount an extrusion at 45-deg. The plan would be to cut the deflector from a piece of 3/8" black ABS plastic. With some templating and trial and error, I should be able to revise the shape of the deflector to match the curve of the roof above the windshield, like the Prinsu/Bowfin design.
Being t-slot all around, this should be a perfect base on which to mount camping lights, mounts, an awning, a roller on the back (Rhino Rack has a roller that should work perfectly), and other accessories as needed. There is also an "extra" slot on the lower inside of the side rails to conceal a wire. I also like the fact that I could rig up some removable basket sides if I want, or install some airline L-track on some of the cross rails for quick-release tie downs, etc.
I've priced this out and, with the Gamiviti feet, the rack as illustrated should be less than $700.
I am not totally sold on this idea yet--it is not the sleekest or most beautiful design, but I think it looks decent, should be plenty strong, and should be very adaptable.