Bambusiero
SILVER Star
Sorry, don't have enough experience to answer that.
It may be that there is a large range of acceptable behavior, from new fully functioning cats to old barely working ones.
Three way catalytic converters seem to work by temporarily storing chemicals from the gas stream, and then reacting them with the opposite ones, oxygen (when lean), then combustion products (when rich), back and forth.
A functioning cat (and o2 sensors) shows a low pass filter / smoothing action on the downstream signal.
How smooth? Don't know. May vary a lot.
My recent learnings on this is from a 20 year old 230k mile car with cats that got too degraded (coated with ash) to satisfy the ECU.
I did a hot citric / oxalic acid descale restoration process.
While it did make a noticeable difference visually, and the ECU stopped throwing P0420/P0430 MIL codes, it was not a dramatic difference.
It went from spending no time in the middle, to spending maybe 20% in the middle.
In other words, from square wave to notchy square wave, and that was enough for the ECU.
It would cost me $1500 to get a new OEM exhaust manifold w cats on that car, sooo... not gonna happen.
Not nearly as bad on a Landcruiser. Much simpler, and more reasonable aftermarket options.
99 Lexus GS300 - very high OEM build quality. Mandrel bent stainless steel tube header & metallic core cats. Looks almost new after 20 years.
Hot acid re-circulation setup.
It may be that there is a large range of acceptable behavior, from new fully functioning cats to old barely working ones.
Three way catalytic converters seem to work by temporarily storing chemicals from the gas stream, and then reacting them with the opposite ones, oxygen (when lean), then combustion products (when rich), back and forth.
A functioning cat (and o2 sensors) shows a low pass filter / smoothing action on the downstream signal.
How smooth? Don't know. May vary a lot.
My recent learnings on this is from a 20 year old 230k mile car with cats that got too degraded (coated with ash) to satisfy the ECU.
I did a hot citric / oxalic acid descale restoration process.
While it did make a noticeable difference visually, and the ECU stopped throwing P0420/P0430 MIL codes, it was not a dramatic difference.
It went from spending no time in the middle, to spending maybe 20% in the middle.
In other words, from square wave to notchy square wave, and that was enough for the ECU.
It would cost me $1500 to get a new OEM exhaust manifold w cats on that car, sooo... not gonna happen.
Not nearly as bad on a Landcruiser. Much simpler, and more reasonable aftermarket options.
99 Lexus GS300 - very high OEM build quality. Mandrel bent stainless steel tube header & metallic core cats. Looks almost new after 20 years.
Hot acid re-circulation setup.
Last edited: