Today I got stuck in, pulled the batteries, mounts, fan and radiator. This will give me the chance to adjust the steering box and replace the small metal pipe that runs around the head above the water pump to cool the turbo, no leak there but would be a bastard to do on the trail.
The main reason though to pull this lot out is to trial fit the Mercedes electric cooling fan that arrived last week, readers will know my 80 already uses a MK VIII unit to cool the engine and provide serious AC efficiency, so how did it go with the Mercedes unit? Absolutely brilliant!
Before removing the radiator I slipped the Merc unit in, it is a little tight between the battery mounts but could see it would fit, I also noted the gap between the water pump, with the MK 8 unit the gap was around 25mm I expect this to become nearer 45mm or more?
I cut off the mounting tabs and laid the Merc fan complete with shroud in place, I trimmed a part of the fan cowling along the top, this was to get the fan 'bump' over the radiator tank seam. And again cut down a small part of the 50mm protrusion on the bottom edge, the main body of the shroud was not cut at all, lo and behold and unbelievably the main shroud top to bottom is the EXACT size of the radiator core not just close, I mean EXACTLY! Unless you had seen me cutting off the tabs you would have thought it was a factory install, width wise the shroud leaves around 3 cm not covered on one side, whilst the MK 8 fan was good top to bottom fitment wise, it left around 13cm not cooled by the fan, if I had cooling issues with the MK 8 fan I might have blamed that area not being cooled, I didn't so was not bothered, now even more of the core is covered however, that does not necessarily mean better cooling.
To cool a hard working motor in 40+ heat, we know that it is all about CFM that we can pull through the radiator, for this you need a big fan with a decent amount of blades, and those blades need to have a large surface area and with a pitch to draw (more efficient than pushing) plenty of air, and of course to drive that fan a decent electric motor, the MK 8 fan had exactly that to cool the 4.6 V8 gas motor in 1993!
So as per my earlier post I have elected to go for the Mercedes unit, larger in diameter than both the stock VC and MK 8 fans, a much more modern unit and available 'off the peg' to boot. It does have the same seven blades as a stock 80 VC driven fan but they are not as deep in pitch, though this should be made up for by the electric fan having a fitted shroud, something the VC driven 80 does not have.
The three most common Mercedes fans that are worth looking at are rated 400, 600 and 850 watts, I chose the 600W fan, the 400 was a little on the small size, the 850 is a 11 blade behemoth, the 600 as I have discovered is the perfect physical size, but will it be powerful enough, YouTube videos show it to be quite a performer. During my research I noted the 850 watt motor appears to be same physical size as the 600W, and whilst I am unsure if could get the 11 blade fan to fit as neatly as the 7 blade unit (I might try later?) the motor may be an option? Things are not always as easy as that though, the 850 may run faster, if the blades are tuned for 'X' speed then forcing them faster may actually move less air, much in the same way that a boat propeller can be tuned for maximum thrust at certain revolutions, if the same speed then at best I would get is more longevity., that is just a passing thought as opposed to a plan.
So back to the present, the very fact that the shroud fits so snug against the radiator core between the upper and lower tanks it would not be moving about but, just in case I will put a slither of padding between the two before bolting the shroud in permanently.
Now to the electrical side, as mentioned in the previous post this fan is controlled by PWM or pulse width modulation, as I understand it, the motor has a permanent heavy set of cables connected via a set of capacitors, and with some electronic wizardry the fan power is applied by pulses, the longer the pulse the faster the fan runs, and vice verse. There are several advantages to this system for example, the fan has a 'soft' start, this means no big hit on the battery /charging system, with the MK 8 this was not too bad either as it had two speeds but, as I wanted instant AC the fan went from off to flat out with around a 50 amp hit settling at around 30 amps, the max on the Mercedes fan is around 60 amps but starts at around 25% and then goes to 50% for the AC, it is possible to program higher or lower speeds with the PWM controller, for engine temps as well as the AC.
Apart from the soft start I think the manufacturer's of these systems were using the very slow speed to keep under hood temperatures down, this with minimum load and wear, I have a couple of customers with Mercedes, and both have these fans, both start rotating very slowly a short time after the thermostat opens, this way the various other radiators for power steering/transmission are being cooled, whether my system will be set to do this I am not sure if it is necassary.
The fan motor has small air holes which made me think about waterproofing, but it seems the electronics are covered by something called 'conformal coating', I used it many years ago when doing MOD work, it is a sort of spray plastic that dries leaving everything waterproof. And whilst staying with the electronics, the PWM controller is custom built specifically for the Mercedes fan by I believe a stateside company and is also waterproof. I will need a small module made up to suit my dashboard LED's, as one or maybe two outputs on controller are not compatible with my 12v units, other than that the wiring is pretty straightforward. It all sounds good, I just need to see how it works, as always I willl provide the thumbs up or down depending on the outcome.
Thanks for taking the time to read.
Regards
Dave