GX550 Overtrail on CarsandBids

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

studawg

SILVER Star
Joined
Jan 9, 2009
Threads
177
Messages
2,376
Location
SC
First, collusion can mean illegal or secret cooperation. I was intending the latter. No shenanigans intended here.

But please discuss with me your reasoning why you think secret collaboration would be wrong.

My intended purpose would be to hold the seller accountable for a lack of planning, at best (or punishing a possible liar and profiteer, at worst) and help restore balance to the car market by seeing "value" be greatly diminished by just taking it off the lot.

Further, buying this vehicle from a near-random private party of CaB and dealing with a lien is far less convenient than paying MSRP at a dealer where they do all the paperwork and you just drive off. Plus the buyer is going to have to pay the CaB fee. I'm hoping for a sub-MSRP transaction here, even without any collusion.

And let's not pretend that secret collusion doesn't happen on the selling side on BaT and CaB. Several instances of friend accounts and shadow accounts bidding on behalf of sellers. The sites catch it sometimes, but not all the time.
 
What would be ironic, and I'm not saying this is the case, but if studawg was in fact affiliated with the seller in some way and colluding to bring interest to the auction. :rofl:
 
Last edited:
First, collusion can mean illegal or secret cooperation. I was intending the latter. No shenanigans intended here.

But please discuss with me your reasoning why you think secret collaboration would be wrong.

My intended purpose would be to hold the seller accountable for a lack of planning, at best (or punishing a possible liar and profiteer, at worst) and help restore balance to the car market by seeing "value" be greatly diminished by just taking it off the lot.

Further, buying this vehicle from a near-random private party of CaB and dealing with a lien is far less convenient than paying MSRP at a dealer where they do all the paperwork and you just drive off. Plus the buyer is going to have to pay the CaB fee. I'm hoping for a sub-MSRP transaction here, even without any collusion.

And let's not pretend that secret collusion doesn't happen on the selling side on BaT and CaB. Several instances of friend accounts and shadow accounts bidding on behalf of sellers. The sites catch it sometimes, but not all the time.
On the contrary, you are the one that needs to explain yourself. You are the one suggesting some sort of deceptive practice in order to cause undue harm to a seller of his vehicle.
 
I don't understand. What is it that you object to?
I object to any sort of deceptive practice. The pertinent question is, why would theLCproject suggest collusion in order to cause undue harm to someone simply selling their vehicle.
 
What would be ironic, and I'm not saying this is the case, but if studawg was in fact affiliated with the seller in some way and colluding to bring interest to the auction. :rofl:
I dont know who the hell you think you are, but I stated clearly that I have no affiliation with the seller. If you are suggesting I am lying, you need to check yourself.
 
Seller apparently does have some sort of secret reserve set. Either way, his story seems fishy.
"some sort of secret reserve". Do you not know how auctions work? There are two types: reserve and no reserve.
 
(or punishing a possible liar and profiteer, at worst) and help restore balance to the car market

Just admit you're a communist and you think that you are some sort of "car market policeman".

"A fair price is not what you say it is, or what I say it is, its what the market will bear." - Leonard Smalls, played by Randall "Tex" Cobb in Raising Arizona
 
I believe most folks (and certainly mine) problem with this is taking an allocation for a currently hard to get vehicle and then flipping it. If you want to be a car dealer, great, go be one, but IMHO this type of behavior does nothing but push pricing and in many cases, causes a false lack of availability.

In covid times it was toilet paper. I have seen it with Apple AirPods where a black Friday sale was bought out by a couple of individuals then all of them listed on FB marketplace.
 
"some sort of secret reserve". Do you not know how auctions work? There are two types: reserve and no reserve.
Hope you feel better soon.

reserve.jpg


secret.jpg
 
I object to any sort of deceptive practice. The pertinent question is, why would theLCproject suggest collusion in order to cause undue harm to someone simply selling their vehicle.
I’m sorry, I’m lost. What deceptive practice?
 
Gents, y'all need to chill. There was already a LC250 in Bring your trailer, and another one there. It was meant to happen and such is life....

For what is worth, the 250 sold pretty much for what it would have cost from a dealer w/o Market Adjustments. 🙏🏿

Have y'all a happy week. ☀️
 
This is too funny.

Agree with WeWantLCs... Have a good week.
Well good then, we both agree with MeWantLC. People need to chill and not worry about someone else selling their car, and certainly not suggest buyers collude and try to stick it to the seller in some sort of way. The market always sorts itself out, when its left to itself. And an auction open to anyone who wants to bid on it is the best way of letting the market sort itself out.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top Bottom