Remove the actual wires from both dome switches. Then check again.
I'm with you on this line of thinking...but I'm wondering if there is an easier way to test all the Dome switches...
Nick, next time you are set to work on this a bit, I've got a couple measurements for you take.
They are Voltage measurements and intended to identify (for both the Dome and Cig fuses) which side (either Drivers Side (DS) or Passengers Side (PS)) of the fuse is touching the 'hot' (12V+) electrode at the fuse box.
To run this test, you need to:
plug the Black DIMM (Digital Multi Meter) lead into the common ground port on the DIMM
plug the Red DIMM lead into the "V Ω mA μA" port on the DIMM
Turn the dial on the DIMM to measure 20V DC (not AC)...here's the symbols for how you will tell V DC from V AC:
Once you have the DIMM set up properly, to run the test you will have to:
Have the battery cables attached to their proper battery terminals (don't have to tighten them all the way down, just make sure they are making good contact)
Remove the Dome and Cig fuses from the fuse box (remember which goes in which slot...or just do one at a time so you don't have to remember).
Ground the Black DIMM probe to a big hunk of metal...like the door jam...it is better if it bare metal, not painted, but if it is painted, you can just push through a little with the sharp tip of the probe so that it makes good contact.
Then, with the Red probe touch the DS contact in the empty fuse slot where the fuse used to be.
Write down whether it reads 12V or 0V
Then, move the Red probe to the PS contact in the same empty fuse slot...while keeping the Black probe touching ground.
Write down whether it reads 12V or 0V.
Do this for both the Dome and Cig fuse slots and post up which side (for each) reads 12V and which side reads 0V.