To reiterate my thoughts on driving in Baja:
While it is awesome to have a badass off-road machine to tool around in... Most of the beaches in Baja are pretty accessible. Sure, the non-toll roads can suck. Sure, there are going to be stretches where you drive on loose sand and/or whoop-de-whoops for miles at a time. Sure, there are rocks and mountains and plenty of chances to get stuck.
Ok.
But if you leave sooner instead of wasting time and money on modifications, you can take your time. Getting stuck might turn out to be the best thing that happens :
(just imagine... you're out of Coronas, low on food, and only a little water. The sun is nearly down. You strike camp and pull out... only to bury your axle. You engage the locker and somehow you still don't get out. Dangit! But, no worries, you'll just spend one more night and dig out early in the morning. You wake up to get going and POW! Overhead sets peeling in with steady offshore winds feathering the foam off the lip. Unbelievable!! Now aren't you glad you didn't build a better offroad vehicle?)
But seriously: making a vehicle that is good in sand and also capacious enough to be a good surf-mobile is a trick proposition. Either a cruiser or a van will do fine. Hell, I know guys who have done California to Costa Rica in a honda civic, an old chevy station wagon, VW vanagon, built landcruisers, stock lexus, and just about any other rolling platform you choose to name. They all made it. They all got stuck sometimes.
For sand, in my experience, a locker in the rear can be better than 4wd and no locker. Why? Its lighter. All things considered, a 2wd w/ locker should weigh a good 200-400lbs less than a 4wd (once you include knuckles, front solid axle, transfer case, etc etc). Of course, you won't have low gears to choose from. But in sand, low gearing isn't usually much benefit anyway.
I'd choose AT tires, probably 31's. I'd go with an auto tranny (better for sand). A mild lift will help out. A good hand winch is better than an electric winch unless you can rig the electric to work both forward AND backward. Many times in sand you are much better off backing up than getting stuck deeper. Spend the money you save (good hand winch is half the price of a cheap electric) on a good hilift (which is also a second hand winch) and some sand ladders. I've never owned sand ladders, but plan to build/buy them someday.
As for the road to Witch's.... That's one of the worst access roads to excellent surf that you'll find in all of Central America. I've been stuck on that road in three different 4wd trucks, including my own (with rear locker). There was an article back (Peterson's 4wd, I think) in 98 or so about a guy who had an fj60 w/ 31s, locked front and rear who had to winch almost the entire way up from the beach to the park. Don't use it as a basis for your trip as 9 times out of 10, you'll be on much easier roadways. A friend of mine runs a surf tour company with a nice defender 110. They are down at witch's once ever two weeks or so. He has stories of backhoes getting stuck in that mud, and of people hiring excavators to pull the backhoes out. Nasty.
Just looked at that 4x4 van for sale page (thundersgarage). Dude, buy the $4,000 1979 van. Drop in a working A/C (a must). Buy a new battery (always a good idea pre-expedition). Drop a few hundred into a tuneup. Go. Surf. Enjoy. Mexican mechanics can fix a ford, no worries.
Diesel would be better in terms of mileage and all that, but... let's say you do 20,000 miles (thats a HELL of a lot of miles in Central America). If gas and diesel are both $3/gallon, but you get 20mpg out of diesel and only 12mpg out of gas, then your diesel costs will be $3,000 and your gas costs would be $5,000
Big deal. You'll probably spend more than $2,000 finding a diesel 4x4 van that is ready to go to Baja. And you'll probably drive a LOT less than 20,000 miles.
Besides, a ratty old van will blend in better- less chance of getting robbed or ticketed by Federales.
For more reading: go to
http://www.peoplesguide.com/ buy the book. You WON'T regret it (this is the type of book that has extra pages in the back, in case you run out of TP... they know what they are doing) You'll laugh. You'll cry. And it'll probably show you that no matter what you drive you'll A) realize you "should" have done something different, and B) be better equipped than 90% of the people who have done trips like this.