Matt...it sounds like you're trying to keep from buying a FP unless for sure needed is that right when you're talking about the $300 part?
Pat on the back for you, you're doing well IMO in making a diagnosis vs. tossing parts at it.
So here is my advice, it's easy enough to pull the pump. My old '97 FJ80 was sold to a mudder who then became a friend and called me shortly after buying the truck to tell me he had a crank no start issue.
I gave him the, mantra I've said here many many many times when dealing with a CNS (crank no start) you're missing one of three things-
1. Spark
2. Fuel
3. Mechanical
So I told him to shoot some starter fluid or carb spray down the throttle body and see if she fires....she did. Well, he took it to the dealer and they said FP....he took it home and put one in himself. Now, anyone else -B-, Landtank feel free or even CDan to disagree with me; but I have never EVER had a Yota smoke a fuel pump.
My pal, called me again a few weeks (or days) later, CNS again. Ok, enough long boring CNS story.
It turned out the sender/fuel pump bracket thing, (what you see when looking down at the top of the tank) on my old his new FZJ had some corrosion and would not have continuity at all times. Ergo-intermittent CNS. My unfortunate nascent/wannabe wrench following mis-diagnosis from the dealer wasted his $$$ on a new FP.
My suggestion---here is the moral of my story for those I have now put to sleep---is that I'd pull the pump, bench test it, check the sender/bracket and of course see if you can find a short in the FP wiring from the tank on back.
But if there were a short-to-ground we'd be blowing fuses, conversely if it's a positive lead chaffed, sure that could give you the CNS issue.
I'm still a little unclear/confused by why you have no MIL when the pump/sender lead is hooked up and you are KOEO (key on engine off). But unhook it and KOEO and your MIL is now on?
Alright....debate me peeps
Jason AKA Figgy
Pat on the back for you, you're doing well IMO in making a diagnosis vs. tossing parts at it.
So here is my advice, it's easy enough to pull the pump. My old '97 FJ80 was sold to a mudder who then became a friend and called me shortly after buying the truck to tell me he had a crank no start issue.
I gave him the, mantra I've said here many many many times when dealing with a CNS (crank no start) you're missing one of three things-
1. Spark
2. Fuel
3. Mechanical
So I told him to shoot some starter fluid or carb spray down the throttle body and see if she fires....she did. Well, he took it to the dealer and they said FP....he took it home and put one in himself. Now, anyone else -B-, Landtank feel free or even CDan to disagree with me; but I have never EVER had a Yota smoke a fuel pump.
My pal, called me again a few weeks (or days) later, CNS again. Ok, enough long boring CNS story.
It turned out the sender/fuel pump bracket thing, (what you see when looking down at the top of the tank) on my old his new FZJ had some corrosion and would not have continuity at all times. Ergo-intermittent CNS. My unfortunate nascent/wannabe wrench following mis-diagnosis from the dealer wasted his $$$ on a new FP.
My suggestion---here is the moral of my story for those I have now put to sleep---is that I'd pull the pump, bench test it, check the sender/bracket and of course see if you can find a short in the FP wiring from the tank on back.
But if there were a short-to-ground we'd be blowing fuses, conversely if it's a positive lead chaffed, sure that could give you the CNS issue.
I'm still a little unclear/confused by why you have no MIL when the pump/sender lead is hooked up and you are KOEO (key on engine off). But unhook it and KOEO and your MIL is now on?
Alright....debate me peeps
Jason AKA Figgy
Last edited: