Great write up. Thanks for taking the time to do it.
First question:
Why did you keep the 4 speed case? Why didn't you get the adapters for the splitcase and find a splitcase to use?
Second question:
I read through your thread twice but still didn't quite follow what you did as far as sourcing your own parts. What exact parts did you purchase from marlin and what did they cost? What exact parts did you source yourself?
If I understand correctly, you just bought the new tranny output shaft & the adapters and bought a minitruck case to use as the "doubler". What gears are in the minitruck case? What was the total cost all said and done?
Thanks!
1. This answer will also help answer the second part. At the time I was sourcing parts, Marlin did not have the split-case kits available. They also didn't have all the parts they needed to make a toybox for the 3-speed and 4-speed cases.
But your thinking is right, it's stronger and an overall upgrade over my 4 speed case. I did the best I could by doing some mods to it.
2. At the time of my parts sourcing, Marlin had the front adapter kit but didn't have all the parts needed to make a complete toybox. I lucked out because a member (LukeZero) here on the forum was selling essentially the rear adapter kit that goes between the reduction housing and the 4-speed case.
So here's the breakdown:
A. Front Adapter kit from Marlin - approx. $550 (call and they can give you a solid price). That comes with a 2 piece adapter. One part bolts to the back of the H42 tranny. The other piece bolts to the reduction housing of your donor mini-truck case. It also comes with a new output shaft for your tranny. And it also comes with a new bearing for the reduction housing. For a $100 core charge you get the modified reduction housing that fits the new bearing (this is the part I describe earlier that the salesmen forgot to offer to me). And it also comes with a marlin shifter knob.
B. Top-shift mini-truck t-case. You'll take it apart and use the low-range reduction section of the case that includes the shifter. The gears in this case are 2.28:1. But you can buy 4.7:1 gears from Marlin. I got it from my dad. I think he paid about $50 for it. He got it with some axles and other yota junk.
C. Rear adapter from forum member. He was asking $250 for the parts or $300 for the parts and the 4-speed case that was behind it. I paid the $300 so I would have a spare case. It came with the rear marlin adapter plate, a bearing with a machined Al spacer, another two-piece spacer welded together, a transfer case gear with correct spline count, and a new shaft that goes from the reduction housing to the 4 speed case (I think this is the part that Marlin is having a hard time sourcing). Marlin's kit comes with new, longer hardware. I had to buy my own.
$550 (front kit) + $50 (mini case) + $250 (rear kit from forum member) + $20 (new hardware for the rear) + $50 (gaskets & oil) = $920 approximately
So with some shipping I'd say $1000 is about right. When Marlin was selling their complete Toybox I think it was around $1800.