You know I'm following this thread avidly, and ive got a few thoughts on the mileage. For one thing, most folks (and companies) mileage claims are ina perfect world, everything is optimized, etc. I have a 2000 CRV with a 2.0 liter 4 cyl that when everything is perfect, and I mean the day after a tune up, air pressure perfect, etc I get 23 mpg. Put a bike (just a normal bicycle) on my roof rack and my mileage drops as low as 16.
I have a 2015 GTI that averages 33 on the highway, 29 around town, which honestly is phenomenal for a 2.0 liter turbo that makes 240 hp.
These are real numbers calculated through mileage and usage numbers over months.
Now my cruiser, (94 FZJ with a 1FZ, 33's, 3 inch lift, ARB bumper and roof rack) averages 12 in town and 14-15 highway. That's measured the same way over 3 years of regular usage.
If I get to 18 mpg on the highway, that puts my truck back in play for real trips. Right now, I wouldn't drive it to big bend, or Appalachia, etc. I bought it to use, but it's cost prohibitive.
Combine that with horrible performance on the highway, an even worse in the mountains, and my truck just isn't cost effective or capable for what I want it for. My wife has a 2012 Buick Enclave that gets 23-24 on the highway, and weighs in about 500 lbs less than my cruiser, has a v6 that makes about 300 hp and drives with absolute authority. It never feels under powered, and merges exceptionally well. It drove as well at 9000 ft in Colorado as at 700 ft in the ATX.
So I said all that to say, that if a 5.3 or 6.0 liter swap costs me less than 5k, gets me 17-18mpg and provides me with some power to use when we need it, then it's money well spent, and my truck is a keeper. I know here was a lot of apples to oranges in that post, most of the vehicles I mentioned are very modern, very aerodynamic, and have extremely fuel efficient tires etc, but that is true of the donor vehicles in this scenario too. The 6.0 liter out of a Denali pickup gets about 20-22 highway (which is where I'm most looking for improvement) in the stock truck, which is reasonably aerodynamic, and has modern 20 inch wheels and tires. Once you swap those and or lift the truck, that mileage goes down in most cases to 17-18.