Tools,
I don't see any problem having a 10 meter radio running 11 meters if used responsibly. When on the trail low power should be the standard, but if you want to sit in your drive at 10pm and talk skip, or if you are in an emergency situation and trying to reach beyond 4 watts what is the issue? Why does having a HAM liscence make this OK?
Your driveway is probably different, but if you draw a 160mi circle from mine there are several lakes, a bunch of trails, tons of camp sites, etc, where people are likely using CB’s for their intended purpose, not to mention people who use them in town. When you turn on your unit, you can’t hear those low power transmissions, so have no idea how many peoples conversations your drowning out when you key the mic. It’s incredibly rude, basically the same as going over to a hummer site, typing in caps about how their rigs suck and you think it affects their sexual persuasion.
Scenario: You setup a trip, a buddy cant make it till late. You agree on a channel and he is going to call on the radio when he gets close. So your sitting in camp, enjoying a beverage by the fire, waiting for the buddy call to direct him to the site you selected and some asswipe comes blaring in about his new pet gerbil. You can’t change the channel or you will miss the call. Your using the unit as intended and being denied by someone who isn’t.
The emergency situation is a good argument, there have been documented lives saved by illegal CB’s and I have never heard of them being prosecuted. But if your concerned about that type of situation there are much better ways to invest, ham, spot, EPIRB, etc. Most times a cell phone would be better than a CB.
Scenario: You have an emergency in the middle of nowhere, fire up the CB and big amp and start transmitting. The vast majority of users that maybe hearing you can’t get back to you, so you have no idea if anything is being done? If you have a ham or even a cell phone, then you know contact has been made, can answer questions, etc. Two way communication is better.
Having a ham license makes ham communication, use OK/legal, it isn’t a license to overpower CB. They are two different things, ham is intended for relatively long range, CB is intended for short range.