Kreiten, did you say you have 275/70/18's or 75/18's? I know you're getting a lift, so this will be a moot point, but have you ever had an alignment done? Even when I had the Duratracs on, I never had any rubbing issues, so I'm wondering if an alignment might help? Mine are 70/18's, so if you do have 75/18's, that wouldn't help. Just a thought.
Also, I can't really say that I recommend wheel spacers, BUT, I did run them on my 4Runner for six years and never had any problems. Obviously, an aftermarket wheel with the correct offset is the way to go, but like you, I also like the looks of the stock wheel, so if it's any consolation, and you decide to run the stock wheel, I was pretty happy with my Spidertrax spacers.
Also, I can't really say that I recommend wheel spacers, BUT, I did run them on my 4Runner for six years and never had any problems. Obviously, an aftermarket wheel with the correct offset is the way to go, but like you, I also like the looks of the stock wheel, so if it's any consolation, and you decide to run the stock wheel, I was pretty happy with my Spidertrax spacers.