I agree with everyone that hates RTT's. I also agree it is a matter of personal choice. Any roof storage is gone. Height clearance is always cut down. Top heavy. The list goes on for me. But they do give that I go camping image and it is a talking piece. I think if you go on short weekend trips and don't need the extra storage on top and don't mind spending the money I guess it's kinda a neat way to camp. And you don't mind lugging it around and have a tall garage.
I prefer something I can stand up in and walk around. I'm 6'4". I also prefer a queen sized air mattress, sheets, real pillows and a feather tick. I also like to be able to fit 2 camp chairs and a side table in the tent. On the ground where I can walk in and out off. Needs to be set up and broken down in 15min or less. Should not take up that much space.
This is our set up. It's so comfortable for long trips. Even broke a few folks that said they would never go camping. I let them stay in the big house and just pop the two man tent we always carry for my wife and I to sleep in. When they come back for more I stick them in the tent and reclaim the big house.
Can't have that space with a RTT. Less than 1/3 the cost. Not even sure what the difference is with weight. The tent is less than 20lbs not sure the awning but less than 50lbs. Oh yeah, you can also just set up the awning super quick. That comes in use every year when we go to Ocracoke island out on the beach. Killing a lot of birds with one stone that weighs 3. Not 30 stone and serves one purpose.
View attachment 2700198
View attachment 2700199
View attachment 2700200
View attachment 2700201
I've run the ARB room as well but it also carries some of the issues that plague a roof top tent and in some ways it's worse. Similar to an RTT your campsite/tent/vehicle are all tied together. Once you set up the awning, room, bedding you are locked in. You can't leave base camp. Setting up the room actually takes longer than any RTT setup I've run since you have to set up the awning first and then the room along with its dozens of clips. The room itself is quite bulky and takes up quite a bit of space in the vehicle and folding it back down to fit into the bag is like trying to roll up any tent and trying to stuff it into the sack. The room is essentially a brick in the wind and if you've ever been in high winds that are strong enough to lift up your awning and flip it over then well I wouldn't want to be in a room that is essentially attached to an awning.
The awning rooms are nice in that you can stand up in them, have basically open walls all around if you choose to, and they make great annexes or hang out spaces. I'm not trying to poo poo on your setup and everyone has a setup that they prefer but as far as using awning rooms as a tent I never found them to be very speedy, convenient, nor flexible. I think they're okay if you're going to stay in one spot for a few days but I typically only stay one night at a spot and move on the next day so the awning room setup never worked for me. Just things to think about for those exploring this option.