Based on experience the foam on top tends to rot out the top of the radiator. More important is a rubber or foam strip between the radiator and the fan guard to prevent electrcal problems between dissimilar metals. Also maintain the rubber insulating bolts holding the radiator to the cruiser.I have also found that the plastic top Toyota radiators to be poorly built and can not recommend them. 2 cents Mike
Not sure how the foam liner can "rot" out the radiator. The fan shroud on my 80 is made of plastic not metal. My original OEM radiator lasted for 16 years and 180,000 miles. I'd call that pretty well built.
Pete