Finally finished the gutter reseal. I'll offer a few pics and suggestions for the next guy who finds this thread.
1. If you use the 3M Ultra Pro Urethane sealant, don't leave it on the concrete floor of your garage for a week at 45 degrees and then pick it up and drop it in the gun and expect it to flow. I was really pissed at the Astro gun that kept breaking, so I superglued it together, but never thought to warm up the sealant. Whoops. I can see maybe going with something more liquid, but there were locations where it's viscosity did help (a-pillars and back gutter).
2. Plan plenty of time to get the old stuff all the way out. If it's failed, it'll pop off in 5 seconds with a thumbnail, if not, it'll take some banging. I used a lead filled dead drop hammer, and a vice grips around an old tiny flat head screwdriver (the kind for eye glasses). See pic below.
3. If you have the wire wheel in your hand and see a tiny bubble in the paint and think to yourself, "Oh, I'll just hit that real quick and prime and paint it fresh". DON'T. (or do, but be prepared to weld or fix holes).
4. You might want to be extra sure it's your gutters that are the culprit. I would recommend taping your windshield (both metal to gasket, and gasket to glass) and seeing if the leak stops FIRST. (After I spent hours and hours replacing mine, priming, painting, I washed my rig and it was still leaking.) Also, consider anything drilled through the A-pillar (like my antenna). I eventually went to a local windshield place (Associated Glass in Lynnwood), and they crawled all over with a flashlight while they hit it with a hose and found I had 'weeping' rust spots in both lower corners of the windshield that were all the way through (and the PO hadn't had the windshield sealed - either glass to rubber, or rubber to metal).
5. Make sure you check the seam under the gutter rail on the a-pillar. Mine fell off as soon as I touched it and had quite a bit of rust underneath.
I used a rust converting primer by Duplicolor that was sandable and paintable after wire wheeling. I used a gray primer and a bottle of single stage custom mixed OEM color touch up paint.
Here's a few pics.
Magic tools:
Untitled by
theophilus76, on Flickr
Massive funnel under a horribly fitting antenna (never seen a 60 with the antenna on the A-pillar till this one)
Untitled by
theophilus76, on Flickr
Underside of A-pillar gutter (front door jam) - OLD sealer and rust patch when I picked at it with my thumbnail.
Untitled by
theophilus76, on Flickr
Whoops
Untitled by
theophilus76, on Flickr
How to keep from scratching everything when wheeling the gutter out
Untitled by
theophilus76, on Flickr
Taped and wheeled - you can see the seam right at the edge of the gutter
Untitled by
theophilus76, on Flickr
Whoops - before sealing
Untitled by
theophilus76, on Flickr
After priming/rust converting and applying Ultra Pro
Untitled by
theophilus76, on Flickr
Whoops after Fiberglass/Bondo - hope it doesn't leak
Untitled by
theophilus76, on Flickr
Whoops completed
Untitled by
theophilus76, on Flickr
Gutter after painting
Untitled by
theophilus76, on Flickr