Now it's making a liar out of me, those I suppose in a good way. After finishing up interior stuff for the day I hopped under again. Shift it from 2H to 4L about 30 times fast and the seal is staying put. I'm not going to leave it "finger tight," but I guess it could have been that it wasn't fully seated? The tcase shaft is fine, no scarring, nice and smooth.
For a "tool," I suppose a short length of pipe with an ID just larger than the shaft OD? Few light taps with a mallet?
Pics are shaft in (2H) and out (4).
Yep, I would agree that it just isn't fully seated.
I was also thinking along the line you are of such a tool...thing about a pipe, though, is that surface area of the face of the pipe that will be pushing against the seal might not be wide enough...if you have ever seen the kits for pressing in seals, the faces are almost as wide as the O.D. of the seal itself...problem here is though, that you've got to have a hole in the middle of the tool only slightly larger than that shaft, or you can't get it about the shaft...so you might have to settle for a pipe...just be careful and press slowly, evenly and firmly, trying not to let it slip...
Also remember, after you've got it set in as good as you can, when you drive it around, you can always monitor the fluid level in the transfercase (open the fill hole and add fluid until it pours back out of the fill hole) and keep enough in there so it doesn't go dry. That seal is pretty high up on the transfercase, too...even under the heat and pressure, I'm wondering how forgiving it would be if it pops off while you are driving if it'll keep enough fluid in there to prevent a catastrophe...
I was looking at his pics from post #100 in this thread, not the ones of the seal actually popping out.