How about neither? Not a HF fan. I am, however, growing to appreciate HF more than I used to. Just picked up a great tile saw on a 4th of July sale with a 2 year warranty and it is performing just as nicely as the rental units, but for the cost of maybe 4 days rent.
I had a HF floor jack once and I can remember vividly an uncommanded load drop of about 2". The jack was just sitting there with a the front of a car in the air and I heard a 'pop' and saw the car bounce. Must have been an air bubble or maybe some debris next to a seal. It worked fine after that, I just never trusted it again. Not that you should trust a jack of any brand, but we all have at one point I'm sure.