I started this thread to get the help with some of the issues with this remodel and now I need some advice.
The various pictures in this thread show the three layers of siding on the house. The first is the original cedar which is about 7/8" thick. The second is the fake brick which is about 3/4" thick. The top layer is asbestos tile.
So, when I framed the new walls, I framed them so the exterior matches the original framing. If you do the math, you'll find that I need to make up 1 1/2" from the framing to install the top layer of siding. That is 2 layers of OSB and layer of 3/4 something.
I really don't want that much sheeting on the house. On the back side, the difference is more like 2 inches so there I am just going to use some 5/4 cedar and wrap it over the mismatch. Should be fine.
I could do the same on the south side but I thought it would look kind of half ass - like I'm trying to cover something up (which of course I am). I also think the extra half inch or so on the back makes it more acceptable.
What to do? I've pretty much set the new wall by installing the window. I did two layers of OSB which matches up perfectly with the original cedar. By doing this, I think I have forced myself to remove all the remaining siding down to the cedar. Doing that requires me remove the two bedroom windows because they have been spaced out 3/4" to match the existing. Again no big deal just takes time. I would also have to redo the interior trim on one of the windows.
This would also set me up to re-side later with hardiplank. I think this is the right way to do things but will certainly add a significant amount of time.
So, any opinions or other ideas?
A couple of pictures.
Pic 1: Back of house (west side). You can see where the new matches up with the old. I think a piece of cedar installed vertically on the old and a small piece ripped to attach to the 2" difference.
Pic 2: South side of house. You should be able to see how nicely 2 layers of OSB matches the cedar. All the siding from the top of the windows down has been removed before. This is about a 25 foot run.