Advice: 2009 Averaging 8.5 MPG (3 Viewers)

[Griffinstrings]

Hi, Recently picked up a 09 with 254k. I'm currently averaging 8.5 mpg on my 5 mile flat daily commute to work. I'm using 87 octane, babying the accelerator, and averaging around 45-50 mph on the commute. Have changed plugs, valve cover gasket, air filter, greased drive shaft, etc. I've ordered new fuel filter. There is a moderate lift and 295/75/17 Grapplers running 40 psi on the vehicle. Other than a possible valley plate issue, the vehicle drives perfectly. Any advice on troubleshooting the mpg would be greatly appreciated. Thanks! Chris in Birmingham, AL

 

[Sandroad]

That sounds about right for a very short commute on very large tires. How are you calculating mpg? If you’re doing it with no correction for large tire size, it will come out low. If you want to take further action (that I doubt will help much), see what others think about a new PCV valve, new oxygen sensors, or mass air flow sensor cleaning.

 

[Griffinstrings]

Thanks for response! I'm referencing the digital readout since last fill up. Good idea on the PCV valve.

 

[AZLX570]

250k+ miles, 34"+ aggressive(ish) tires, lifted, and under highway speeds? I'd calculate it by hand furst but ~10mpg doesn't seem too far out of the norm if that 5 miles is stop and go traffic. At under 5 miles it's probably barely getting up to operating temperature.

 

[Griffinstrings]

Thanks! I think mentally double digits are acceptable and single are not!

 

[Boston Mangler]

Unpopular opinion:

Larger tires alter speedo, which alters odo, which alters MPG calculations

Until speedo/odo is corrected, youll never get an accurate MPG calc

To test this, get a GPS, get it to 65mph, check speedo, put on stock wheels, do the same thing. It will all makes sense

 

[turbo8]

Hi, Recently picked up a 09 with 254k. I'm currently averaging 8.5 mpg on my 5 mile flat daily commute to work. I'm using 87 octane, babying the accelerator, and averaging around 45-50 mph on the commute. Have changed plugs, valve cover gasket, air filter, greased drive shaft, etc. I've ordered new fuel filter. There is a moderate lift and 295/75/17 Grapplers running 40 psi on the vehicle. Other than a possible valley plate issue, the vehicle drives perfectly. Any advice on troubleshooting the mpg would be greatly appreciated. Thanks! Chris in Birmingham, AL

View attachment 3954830

View attachment 3954831

What fuel filter did you buy? US 200's didn't come with fuel filters, it has a mesh sock inside the tank though.

Are you brakes dragging?

 

[gaijin]

Hi, Recently picked up a 09 with 254k. I'm currently averaging 8.5 mpg on my 5 mile flat daily commute to work. I'm using 87 octane, babying the accelerator, and averaging around 45-50 mph on the commute. Have changed plugs, valve cover gasket, air filter, greased drive shaft, etc. I've ordered new fuel filter. There is a moderate lift and 295/75/17 Grapplers running 40 psi on the vehicle. Other than a possible valley plate issue, the vehicle drives perfectly. Any advice on troubleshooting the mpg would be greatly appreciated. Thanks! Chris in Birmingham, AL

View attachment 3954830

View attachment 3954831

I was going to do a simple calc to adjust for your tire size, but I cant find "295/75R17" tires anywhere. Are you sure about that size?

 

[grinchy]

I get around 10 in the city. The digital gauge will show between 8.5 and 10. Usually shows 12 or less on the highway.

Actual is 8% higher, I’m running 34.5” (35x10,5x17) tires and have 4.88 gears. The gears don’t change the odometer like the tires do, but they do make driving fun again.

 

[LX Cruiser]

I'm currently averaging 8.5 mpg on my 5 mile flat daily commute to work. I'm using 87 octane, babying the accelerator, and averaging around 45-50 mph on the commute.

That sounds off to me. How long does your truck typically idle before you leave? That is factoring in an mpg of 0. Sitting at long stoplights does the same thing...

Also wondering if you've got a parking brake dragging

 

[gaijin]

Hi, Recently picked up a 09 with 254k. I'm currently averaging 8.5 mpg on my 5 mile flat daily commute to work. I'm using 87 octane, babying the accelerator, and averaging around 45-50 mph on the commute. Have changed plugs, valve cover gasket, air filter, greased drive shaft, etc. I've ordered new fuel filter. There is a moderate lift and 295/75/17 Grapplers running 40 psi on the vehicle. Other than a possible valley plate issue, the vehicle drives perfectly. Any advice on troubleshooting the mpg would be greatly appreciated. Thanks! Chris in Birmingham, AL

View attachment 3954830

View attachment 3954831

I was going to do a simple calc to adjust for your tire size, but I cant find "295/75R17" tires anywhere. Are you sure about that size?

In the absence of a response, just to give an example of how a different (larger) tire size can adversely affect mileage compared to the stock tire, let's assume you are actually referring to a LT285/75R17 Nitto Recon Grappler A/T tire:

Stock tire is 285/60R18 which has a nominal Revolutions per Mile spec of 661

Your tire is 285/75R17 which has a nominal Revolutions per Mile spec of 614

661-614 = 47 / 661 = 0.07 (or 7%)

Which means the 285/75R17 tire will rotate 7% fewer revolutions per mile than the stock tire.

While the data on your dash thinks your truck has gone 100 miles based on the diameter of the stock tire, it has actually travelled 7% more, 107 miles, on your larger tires.

So... just based on tire size alone, when you calculate an average MPG of 8.5 MPG based on data from your dash, the actual average MPG is 8.5 * 1.07 = 9.1 MPG.

But, as has been mentioned, the best way to find out exactly what your MPG is would be to measure distance with a standalone GPS unit, and keep accurate records of fuel added at each fill-up. Mo' data, mo' betta.

HTH

 

[Ratchey]

I have an 09 with 152K on it. My girlfriend drives about 10 miles each way to work. COuple of stop signs, couple of stop lights and country road and highway mix. We get 12. 16 on a good day on a road trip. (not very flat in NW Montana) Not abnormal.

 

[Boston Mangler]

To

But, as has been mentioned, the best way to find out exactly what your MPG is would be to measure distance with a standalone GPS unit, and keep accurate records of fuel added at each fill-up. Mo' data, mo' betta.

This

 

[Sandroad]

Thanks for response! I'm referencing the digital readout since last fill up. Good idea on the PCV valve.

Thanks for response! I'm referencing the digital readout since last fill up. Good idea on the PCV valve.

That’s important info. Definitely hand calculate mpg over a few fillups. I don’t know what sensors or algorithms the dash readout uses, but on my ‘17 the digital readout is way low.

 

[TeCKis300]

8.5 MPG is a little low but not out of the question for a short commute with lots of stop and go. The 200-series is very inefficient in that kind of commute given it's heavy weight. Every stop is throwing away energy. Using more gas to accelerate again at the next light. Stock rating at best was 13MPG city.

Combine that with lift, R/T tires which do not prioritize rolling resistance, compromised gearing needing a lot of throttle, and possibly a heavy foot...

Here's what my MPG looks like straight off the gauge. My commute and trips are similar as I commute in town only. I have a heavy foot. Although I'm on 37" R/Ts so you should be doing a bit better than this. With 35 A/Ts, I was getting about 9-10.5 MPG readouts. With 33s A/Ts that were really close to your size in diameter, about 10-11.5MPG, which is what I'd expect for your setup.

Yes, definitely change the PCV if you don't know when it was last serviced. You should also be correcting for tire diameter as mentioned. Short answer is take what your readout says and multiply by 1.05.

My 8.6 corrected (1.10 for 37s) is 9.5 MPG. It's pretty close to hand calculated MPH.

Still bad but it's pay to play and smiles per mile.

 

[CharlieChops]

I track my mpg on fuelly. It just does a really straightforward calculation of miles traveled - gas consumed.

 

[Boston Mangler]

I track my mpg on fuelly. It just does a really straightforward calculation of miles traveled - gas consumed.

But your Odo is off, like the speedo so that data is flawed also, for the same reasons

 

[LX Cruiser]

I have an 09 with 152K on it. My girlfriend drives about 10 miles each way to work. COuple of stop signs, couple of stop lights and country road and highway mix. We get 12. 16 on a good day on a road trip. (not very flat in NW Montana) Not abnormal.

Same vehicle here. 202k miles. My corrected mpg is 13 city, 16-17 hwy with a Thule cargo carrier up top. In Western states at 80mph+, that drops to 13-14.

I have a 5.7L Tundra as well. 4.3 gearing (as opposed to the early 200s with 3.91), heavy 285/75R18s. Worst I can get in that thing when flooring it everywhere if one job goes later than expected is 11mpg (corrected).

I still think something is wrong with OP's 200. Or he idles a LOT.