Trip to the dealer today..... $4,164 later....

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

OEM shocks are $29 ea when you know a place that gives a great discount. At that dealership they are likely full retail. And while they make take you 20 minutes to replace, according to the hour book they may bill out at 2 hours of labor.

You do understand that it's a business's job to make money and it's a service department's job to point out things that could need repair? They're not forcing you to do it. They advise you. I think it's even in their job title. They don't know when it's going to fail, if it even is. But you can sure as hell bet if they didn't mention the problem and it did fail, it's their fault for not catching it.

What exactly is your sternly worded letter going to say? "Your dealership tried to point out problems for repair that could case me bigger problems later. Then they had the audacity not to read my mind or check the thousands of parts they sell to see if I'd purchased coolant from them. Furthermore, they want to charge me a normal price for shocks and they don't know that I know Dan. How dare they."

It's your opinion, and opinions are never wrong by definition, so have at it.

However, I believe (my opinion) that this dealership was out to perform services that were not needed (fluid changes, fuel rail cleaning, etc) rather than make note of potential problems they may have actually seen during an ACTUAL inspection.

As an ADVISOR, to be good and competent at your job, you MUST first LISTEN, then ask appropriate questions, and finally offer suggestions based on KNOWLEDGE and EXPERIENCE. The Service Writer offers a list of to-do items without asking if they had recently been addressed, didn't base his estimates on the KNOWLEDGE that the fluid changes had not been completed (didn't ask, so he wouldn't know), and then gave pricing for services that were not required nor needed at the time.

Not quite the ADVISOR I would go back to or trust in the future.

Shock blown? How did they determine this diagnosis? Owner hasn't complaned of any symtomatic signs of a bad shock. $368 for $90-parts and 4-hours labor? That's what happens when you have your head up your ass looking at a book instead of going by what any OTHER shop would do - give an estimate based on EXPERIENCE.

MY experience tells me that this would take 1-hr. If I charged 1.5-hrs to make sure I had it right at $90/hr, I would have a grand total of $135 in labor. Add $90 in full-blown retail for the shocks, and you're at $225. $368 is stupidly over-inflated BS malarkey.

$400+ for what essentially is a bottle of BG-44K shot into the fuel rails and another added to the tank? Takes 30-min for the work and about $40 in RETAIL pricing for the supplies, plus the use of the equipment. Most shops would charge $100-$130 for this. $400+???? REALLY???

I've been to WAY too many dealers who operate this way. The HONEST ones are few and far between, and that will even change when the current service mgr parts ways and a new guy takes over.

Just sayin'...
 
Last edited:
2000 with 117k .... I about wet myself when he called.

Took it in to have the CV boots replaced.... They have both been split & leaking & running dry for about 60k miles - was expecting them to tell me i needed new joints, but surprisingly they said they are ok... were $642 to replace the boots. This seems about on par with what I have seen from others. I am a :banana::banana: mechanic and didnt feel like I could tackle this on my own.

They did their usual multi point inspection and 'the truck checks out great except for the following 4 things'....

First, if you did change the fluids and they were recommending and I was the adviser, there would be hell to pay as NOTHING is more embarrassing than a fawking lazy ass tech that does not check and I have written up and fired techs for this act.

Please understand that most tech's do their job very well and by doing that it includes full inspections and these are noted on the inspection as I hope that you would not only want but would expect.

The adviser as myself is a translator to the client from the tech's notes. Coming from a High Line store my client base will not stand for any oil leaks and will pay $5,000 for case half reseal on a North Star and it requires removal of the engine. and I hate doing them as it ties up a stall for 3 days. But that's not my call.

The average repair order at any Toyota store is about 1.8 hours per. I run 3.8 at a GMC, Pontiac and Buick store. They write 3 times more than I do, but some people believe that they don't have to do any maintenance and it will go forever. Knock yourself out. Myself, I change every oil in my rigs every 10 miles because I can, meaning being an employee it costs me pennies and lunch for a tech. So every other LOF it's getting everything except coolant.

I look under my 100 and I see the rack is soaking wet, but not dripping and I know it's going to suck to do, but I won't do it, Toyota will.

I had my 100 next door "Gladstone Toyota" for a rear wheel bearing last month. Where two of the advisers have been there for 15-20 years. Jenny is my FAV, while Peggy is a bitch to work with she is awesome with customers. Anyway, the tech I hired and a friend that could do side work if I asked him to did my inspection, he called and said get over here. Ok, lower ball joints are loose and rear inside pads are at 1mm (my tech missed) so I had him do it all. I went to get it and the service manager had internalized 14 hours of labor and I only paid for parts. That was nothing I had asked for and was way beyond good business, even if I was an ex employee. But I refer a lot of work, parts sales and sales to them and they (owner and service manger) thought it was time to give back. Since then, I have had 2 follow up calls from outside call center asking about my experience and 2 online surveys. This is from a HUGE Toyota dealer that cares, some don't and don't have to. But NONE are a like. I DEMAND to know what what issues or concerns my truck my have! as should you.

This store goes out of its way for me on parts sales. I get 10% over cost which is below employee cost and I could ruin all the online part whores out there and they would drop ship, but this is a business and I wont no part of that brain damage. So with that, if you ask questions and ask to be shown what they are recommending then you will get an idea and then make a call on what is important at that time or what to watch.



don't walk, run. see if you can find a good independent or a fellow cruiserhead to help. that's insane and the fluid change is just icing on the proverbial cake. the sad thing is they do it (aggressive upselling) because most people are ignorant and it works.

I have been screwed so many times thinking this, it's not the case all the time. You get better techs and better info at the dealer, most of the time. But I will never sell outside of manufacture supported recommendations unless there is a reason.


i just sawzalled off the rears...took me about five minutes.
:confused:

1. Glad you're not falling for it.

2. Post the dealer name, and if possible, the service advisor that fed you that line of bull. When people google the dealer name or the service writer's name, this thread will then pop up. Google is your friend... when you're HONEST.

3. OEM shocks are $29 each, and take all of 20-min each to change. Most of that time is consumed by jacking up each side and removing the wheel so you can get in there to work. Fronts are cake and a half-banana job at most.

4. You should write a STERNLY worded letter to the manager/owner of the dealership how his service advisor was attempting to STEAL your money on the fluid changes, shock prices, etc and how you intend to file your letter with the BBB and Toyota corp. Make sure to include your phone number so he can call you and offer a bribe, er I mean "discount" for your next visit. Use the coupon he gives you for parts, then take them and put them on yourself or get another shop to do the labor.

5. Good luck in your search for a DECENT, HONEST shop.

There is some hate there, you can't think your right and expect to sell that? Dude, I will sit and talk all day long and educate you from both sides, as Toyota and LEXUS will not fawk around with that your stating.

They don't know when it's going to fail, if it even is. But you can sure as hell bet if they didn't mention the problem and it did fail, it's their fault for not catching it.

What exactly is your sternly worded letter going to say? "Your dealership tried to point out problems for repair that could case me bigger problems later. Then they had the audacity not to read my mind or check the thousands of parts they sell to see if I'd purchased coolant from them. Furthermore, they want to charge me a normal price for shocks and they don't know that I know Dan. How dare they."

Then there's that. .



Shane
 
Last edited:
And if it's one thing I've learned in 15 years of customer service - sometimes people have continually bad experiences places because they're a bad customer.

Well, maybe if you'd lighten up a bit and not be such a bad customer, you'd eventyually have a good experience... :rolleyes:
 
Toyota does not sell the hose by itself. The Toyota power steering high pressure hose price is for the whole assembly. Brock had his local mechanic fix it with a hose. We need the hose size because I need to fix mine as well.

See post #144

https://forum.ih8mud.com/100-series...ucing-my-dirty-little-diva-8.html#post6269616

I sent an email to Brock.

I am getting the info...he is in middle of moving his whole shop from the hid away industrial park that nobody can find except word of mouth.....to a shop facing a main road here in town...so it should help his business significantly as he stays busy from word of mouth now. Once he is settled or if I go by this week to see how he is coming or if he needs any help I will get info. Those hoses out of resevoir get hard as a brick and start cracking and leaking on the ends no matter how much you tighten..until you end up breaking the nipple on resevoir from tightening too much. No more leaks...so I am happy man. :)

Price I saw was $600 for the entire assembly on the Toyota parts ordering site used by my buddy...they dont sell the individual hoses or at least we could not find them. My hose is the low pressure side not high pressure...as it is the hoses coming off resevoir not coming out of pump housing...two different beasts when doing a FIX IT REPAIR. If it was high pressure side I dont think this would have worked. Once I have the specifics and sizes I will post it up for all as a alternative to buying the whole assembly which includes rubber and hard lines both.
 
It sounds very similar to an 80. The steering hoses are in an expensive kit and it's usually only the hp one that leaks. There was a hose from a Previa that worked, but the last one of those in the country sold a long time ago. It turned out generic 3/8" hp line would work, but getting it on the barb was a real chore.
 
I have been screwed so many times thinking this, it's not the case all the time. You get better techs and better info at the dealer, most of the time. But I will never sell outside of manufacture supported recommendations unless there is a reason.

There is some hate there, you can't think your right and expect to sell that? Dude, I will sit and talk all day long and educate you from both sides, as Toyota and LEXUS will not fawk around with that your stating.
e

If your claim is that dealer employees lean towards being more professional than less, I might agree, but just this past week David Wilson Toyota in Las Vegas, took one look at my LC and tried to tell me I needed to replace a front CV boot that was leaking. Didn't ask me about the history, didn't ask me about any recent work that was performed, just took a look at some grease that was on the inside of the tire and quoted me a total replacement of the CV boot. I was simply handed an estimate and told that it needed to be replaced.

The problem? I had an off-road shop in Texas replace the CV boot three weeks prior. Former Lexus service advisor, too. Very reputable place, excellent work and it adequately fixed the leaking CV boot concurrent with my upgrade to OEM shocks, springs, etc. The grease that remained was something that I was supposed to clean after the off-road shop performed the work(mutual agreement). The Toyota dealer simply saw the grease and assumed it leaking, didn't inspect it, and recommended replacing it again. Even though the part was new.

That's called ethics. He's in a position of trust regarding the vehicle and he's preying on my putting faith in him to be honest about a particular problem. Needless to say, I explained directly to the dealer what they could do with the estimate.

If you have the diagnosis of a problem done(and confirmed) separately from a dealer, then I would say I trust a dealer to do the work. But I won't ever let a dealer 'diagnose' my vehicle, even if it's on fire.

Nothing against the honest, hardworking people that work in dealerships(not being sarcastic, I believe people are good), the entire business model of dealerships creates incentives to bill for unnecessary work.
 
Most of Aatlas comments are spot on. I was a service adviser at a dealer and techs would bring me all sorts of stuff they wanted to sell. It took a while to figure each tech and get some of them not to try and upsell 20 hours on every other car. Service advisor isn't always the easiest job and definitely not the easiest way to make s*** money listening to whiny people who usually aren't good customers.

My advice if you question a dealers recommendations.... Have them show you the problem.
 
Back
Top Bottom