When I went from the stock 275/60R18 to my current 275/70R18, the two biggest effects I noticed were braking and acceleration. The LC100 has pretty good brakes to begin with, so it didn’t feel like braking suffered too greatly. Acceleration on the other hand was greatly noticed (yes, I have stock gearing). With the stock tires, my LC felt like it could practically pull a wheelie. Now, not so much. I test drove a fellow Mudder’s LC100 and he has 315/75R16 Toyo MT. Wow, those felt heavy (but he has stock gearing). There was no doubt he was rolling on 35’s.
On my ’94 Toyota Pickup, I ran 33’s, but ran 35’s for about 6 months (with factory 4.88 gears). I hated the increased stopping distance and the very poor acceleration. I swapped them out for 33’s, which were manageable.
Hardly anyone talks about tire weight because it’s the unavoidable evil, we just suck it up as we roll off-road with greater ground clearance and beefier sidewalls.
Six months ago I too looked at the Toyo AT2 “Xtreme” sizes. From what I read back then, it was the MT tread that was 10-15 pounds heavier per tire. The regular AT2 and AT2 Xtreme were pretty close in weight. I wonder if the latest specs have a typo. The 285/65R18 XT used to weigh 58 pounds, and now it’s 69. That’s a big jump.