I agree that basic Spike isn’t a 4.5, but I have done much easier trails, maybe I need a 100?

Like most trails it’s the optional obstacles that get you, the vertical wedgie, running the left side of golden stairs, Double Whammy, etc. The basic trail is probably a strong 3.5, I would up it to 4.0 for length and remoteness, recovering broken rigs from there is a bitch. Taking the most aggressive lines can easily up it to a 4.5.
It’s my favorite Moab trail, not because it’s “hard”, it’s the varied obstacles combined with the fantastic scenery that does it for me. There is little dirt road screwing around, the obstacles start early and keep coming, steps, wedgies, crack, big ups and downs, off camber, red rock, slick rock, a little of everything, with little time to be bored.
Sorry but IMHO,
SPIKE FRICKEN ROCKS!
